Go Back  Airline Pilot Central Forums > Airline Pilot Forums > Major > United
Reassignment/Pay for an AA guy. >

Reassignment/Pay for an AA guy.

Search

Notices

Reassignment/Pay for an AA guy.

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 06-18-2023, 07:40 AM
  #21  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Oct 2015
Position: Gear slinger
Posts: 2,980
Default

Originally Posted by Sunvox
I am not sure your post proves what you think it does.

Someone from Delta correct me if I am mistaken, but the truth is at Delta the schedulers don't need a reason to reassign someone, but at least now they get paid . . . well at least starting in August. At United there are numerous but specific conditions that can trigger a reassignment most of which you listed. If you have not had one of those "triggered" reasons then you are "untriggered" and paid enormously well.

I was untriggered twice as a 777 FO going from TLV to HKG and it ended up being about equal to a whole months pay. It's 225% of the new trip plus pay for working on a day off PLUS you get the day off back. As I understand it Delta does NOT restore lost days off for lineholders even in the new contract.

Here are some items we have better than Delta. Some of these items are what I would consider "huge".

We can refuse to extend FAR 117 duty time and if we extend sometimes we get paid; at Delta the culture is to NEVER refuse, and the don't get paid extra.
We have IRO lines; they do not.
We get our days off restored; they do not.
We have defined minimum days off for lineholders; they do not.
Our SC callout is defined; theirs is "promptly" and open to company interpretation.
We get meals; they get them sometimes.
Our LTD is tax free; their's is not.
Our LTD pays FOs more than theirs.

I'm not talking about current pay rates as obviously that is a separate issue, and yes there are aspects of their contract that are better than ours, but it's not as "slam dunk" better as some seem to think.
Some of your UAL wins, aren’t really wins.

Int’l flights over 12hrs mandate double captains at DAL… more CAs per aircraft.
SC callout defined is not a win Both AA and DAL are undefined, and regularly 3+ hrs from call to show is acceptable.
DAL LTD comes with immediate 401K DC contributions.
Otterbox is offline  
Old 06-18-2023, 11:39 AM
  #22  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: May 2009
Posts: 1,871
Default

Originally Posted by Otterbox
Some of your UAL wins, aren’t really wins.

Int’l flights over 12hrs mandate double captains at DAL… more CAs per aircraft.
SC callout defined is not a win Both AA and DAL are undefined, and regularly 3+ hrs from call to show is acceptable.
DAL LTD comes with immediate 401K DC contributions.
How many 12+ hour flights does Delta have?
JoePatroni is offline  
Old 06-18-2023, 02:15 PM
  #23  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Oct 2015
Position: Gear slinger
Posts: 2,980
Default

Originally Posted by JoePatroni
How many 12+ hour flights does Delta have?
Doesn’t really matter. Without rolled days off, DAL has to account them in their vacancies where at UAL they can just roll a Reserve WB CAs days off and double augment flights (regardless of time for “operational integrity”) at will when it suits them without supplying extra manning opportunities in the form of WB CA vacancies.
Otterbox is offline  
Old 06-18-2023, 04:48 PM
  #24  
Gets Weekends Off
 
NuGuy's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Mar 2008
Posts: 3,913
Default

Originally Posted by Sunvox
I am not sure your post proves what you think it does.

Someone from Delta correct me if I am mistaken, but the truth is at Delta the schedulers don't need a reason to reassign someone, but at least now they get paid . . . well at least starting in August. At United there are numerous but specific conditions that can trigger a reassignment most of which you listed. If you have not had one of those "triggered" reasons then you are "untriggered" and paid enormously well.

I was untriggered twice as a 777 FO going from TLV to HKG and it ended up being about equal to a whole months pay. It's 225% of the new trip plus pay for working on a day off PLUS you get the day off back. As I understand it Delta does NOT restore lost days off for lineholders even in the new contract.

Here are some items we have better than Delta. Some of these items are what I would consider "huge".

We can refuse to extend FAR 117 duty time and if we extend sometimes we get paid; at Delta the culture is to NEVER refuse, and the don't get paid extra.
We have IRO lines; they do not.
We get our days off restored; they do not.
We have defined minimum days off for lineholders; they do not.
Our SC callout is defined; theirs is "promptly" and open to company interpretation.
We get meals; they get them sometimes.
Our LTD is tax free; their's is not.
Our LTD pays FOs more than theirs.

I'm not talking about current pay rates as obviously that is a separate issue, and yes there are aspects of their contract that are better than ours, but it's not as "slam dunk" better as some seem to think.
Extensions at DAL have always been optional per the FARs, but it's been considerably streamlined since 2020. Don't extend or fatigue out for operational reasons and pay is 100%, and they can only connect DH back to your trip or release you. Except for the fringe 9:00 hour FAR duty limits, you'll be making 1:1 additional pay for duty time before you get close to an FAR extension in most cases, so the pay to extend thing is moot, and that duty time pay is calculated report to release, unlike the FARs.

LTD is not capped, and pays the DC contribution portion at x2 (currently 32%)

The day off thing. Dunno, looking at the bottom of a couple of category lists, even the most junior NB line holders are getting 16, 17, 18 days off, and even the very high value lines are getting 14. I didn't see any line holders with 12 or 13 days off. Bottom line holder on the 737 FO in ATL got 16 days off. The pilot two senior to him got 18. Now if your minimum number of days off is 12, and a lot of people are at the minimum, then, yea, I could see why that would be a big deal.

If a reserve is flown into his day off, they get the day off back, plus 9 hours. If they voluntarily fly premium (green slip) on a day off, they still get the day off back, plus 9 hours and their pay on their days off is on top of the reserve guarantee.

Reroutes into days off is fairly rare. If it happens, you get double pay for the scheduled last day (including any credit that is due), plus double pay for what you flew on the day rolled into. Come August, you will also get the leg reroute on top of that, so most times reroutes into another day will pay 300% for the day infringed, plus 250-300% for the last scheduled day.

SC is "you get there when you get there". Don't need people trying to kill themselves to make an artificial deadline. Besides, the traffic in NYC going to one of 3 airports can be vastly different than MSP.
NuGuy is offline  
Old 06-19-2023, 02:13 AM
  #25  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Feb 2017
Posts: 1,383
Default

Originally Posted by NuGuy
Extensions at DAL have always been optional per the FARs, but it's been considerably streamlined since 2020. Don't extend or fatigue out for operational reasons and pay is 100%, and they can only connect DH back to your trip or release you. Except for the fringe 9:00 hour FAR duty limits, you'll be making 1:1 additional pay for duty time before you get close to an FAR extension in most cases, so the pay to extend thing is moot, and that duty time pay is calculated report to release, unlike the FARs.

LTD is not capped, and pays the DC contribution portion at x2 (currently 32%)

The day off thing. Dunno, looking at the bottom of a couple of category lists, even the most junior NB line holders are getting 16, 17, 18 days off, and even the very high value lines are getting 14. I didn't see any line holders with 12 or 13 days off. Bottom line holder on the 737 FO in ATL got 16 days off. The pilot two senior to him got 18. Now if your minimum number of days off is 12, and a lot of people are at the minimum, then, yea, I could see why that would be a big deal.

If a reserve is flown into his day off, they get the day off back, plus 9 hours. If they voluntarily fly premium (green slip) on a day off, they still get the day off back, plus 9 hours and their pay on their days off is on top of the reserve guarantee.

Reroutes into days off is fairly rare. If it happens, you get double pay for the scheduled last day (including any credit that is due), plus double pay for what you flew on the day rolled into. Come August, you will also get the leg reroute on top of that, so most times reroutes into another day will pay 300% for the day infringed, plus 250-300% for the last scheduled day.

SC is "you get there when you get there". Don't need people trying to kill themselves to make an artificial deadline. Besides, the traffic in NYC going to one of 3 airports can be vastly different than MSP.
sounds like reserve at DAL can actually make some money if they want. VS us at UAL where it’s tough to actually break guarantee (73), plus our reserve rules sucking hard on top of that.
JTwift is offline  
Old 06-19-2023, 05:17 AM
  #26  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: May 2009
Posts: 1,871
Default

Originally Posted by Otterbox
Doesn’t really matter. Without rolled days off, DAL has to account them in their vacancies where at UAL they can just roll a Reserve WB CAs days off and double augment flights (regardless of time for “operational integrity”) at will when it suits them without supplying extra manning opportunities in the form of WB CA vacancies.
If it’s only a handful of flights it doesn’t really move the needle, United publishes the relief captain spots in the bid package so they are planned ahead of time.
JoePatroni is offline  
Old 06-19-2023, 06:13 AM
  #27  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Sunvox's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Sep 2010
Position: EWR 777 Captain
Posts: 1,715
Default

Originally Posted by NuGuy
Extensions at DAL have always been optional per the FARs, but it's been considerably streamlined since 2020. Don't extend or fatigue out for operational reasons and pay is 100%, and they can only connect DH back to your trip or release you. Except for the fringe 9:00 hour FAR duty limits, you'll be making 1:1 additional pay for duty time before you get close to an FAR extension in most cases, so the pay to extend thing is moot, and that duty time pay is calculated report to release, unlike the FARs.
I was told that the culture at Delta is to accept an extension as a norm. I would say the opposite is true at United especially on domestic flights as it is almost always at the end of a fatiguing situation. If this is not the case, my apologies.

Originally Posted by NuGuy
LTD is not capped, and pays the DC contribution portion at x2 (currently 32%)
From our contract comparison ALPA page

As you can see from the examples, the tax-free benefit payments are significant for a UAL pilot who becomes disabled. If the pilot is a FO crediting less than 85.5 hours then the UAL Plan provides an enhancement, as the benefit is calculated as if the pilot flies 85.5 hours. The reverse is also true, in that pilots that credit more than 85.5 hours do not get as much gross benefit compared to the DAL plan.

It is important to note that UAL pilots do collectively pay 35% of the actual cost of the plan and the DAL pilots have premium free coverage. However, UAL pilots do have two seats at the LTD Administrative Committee to assist pilots in assuring their benefits are paid correctly and timely. DAL pilots do not have a seat at the table when it comes to directly administering their LTD plan.

It is also apparent that the DAL pilots have increased retirement contributions compared to the UAL plan. The UAL plan does provide retirement contributions as a tax-free benefit, which is better than tax-deferred, and is not subject to the restrictions on withdrawal that apply to 401(k) plans.

It is also important that in years when the company hits the profit share triggers in the contract, DAL pilots will have their profit-sharing counts towards their earnings so that their LTD payments will be higher than just using their credit hours, the UAL Plan does not use profit sharing payments in the calculation of UAL pilots’ LTD benefits.

Pilots that get disabled shortly after upgrading could be better off in the UAL Plan as UAL uses the higher of a pilot’s hourly rate on January 1 of the year disabled or the pilot’s current hourly rate while DAL uses a 12-month earnings look back.

Pilots living in a state with state disability benefits and pilots with psychological disabilities that last longer than 30 months may also be better off under the UAL Plan. Conversely, pilots with disabilities relating to substance abuse that last longer than 18 months may be better off under the DAL Plan. Which LTD plan is better for you depends on your situation but in the TA, UAL pilots have made significant progress on improving LTD and protecting you and your family in case you become disabled.

Pilots of all ages go on LTD, and they can be junior or senior. As an example, in 2021, the average age of pilots applying for LTD was 51 years old.
Originally Posted by NuGuy
The day off thing. Dunno, looking at the bottom of a couple of category lists, even the most junior NB line holders are getting 16, 17, 18 days off, and even the very high value lines are getting 14. I didn't see any line holders with 12 or 13 days off. Bottom line holder on the 737 FO in ATL got 16 days off. The pilot two senior to him got 18. Now if your minimum number of days off is 12, and a lot of people are at the minimum, then, yea, I could see why that would be a big deal.

If a reserve is flown into his day off, they get the day off back, plus 9 hours. If they voluntarily fly premium (green slip) on a day off, they still get the day off back, plus 9 hours and their pay on their days off is on top of the reserve guarantee.
I should rewrite that line to say "line holders" do not get a lost day off restored at Delta, but United does. I am quoting the ALPA contract comparison guide there so if it is incorrect my apologies.

Originally Posted by NuGuy
Reroutes into days off is fairly rare. If it happens, you get double pay for the scheduled last day (including any credit that is due), plus double pay for what you flew on the day rolled into. Come August, you will also get the leg reroute on top of that, so most times reroutes into another day will pay 300% for the day infringed, plus 250-300% for the last scheduled day.
I took this from a discussion on the ualpilotsforum.info

General observations on how different our contracts are WRT reserve. UA does not like paying premium; Delta likes to keep minimum staffing and uses premium essentially as a replacement to our FSB along with rerouting LHs. Their RSVs can pick up on days off to include premium pay trips. If we have reserves available for a trip in open time then there is technically coverage and no premium would be offered. Once their reserves pick up on the days off they get those days back. Their RSV guarantee can change month to month and is based on ALV-2 (avg. line value). This keeps the company in check; higher line values mean RSV guarantee is higher. In addition to pick up on days off means much more schedule manipulation and add the ability to pick up premium and then get days off recovered equals Reserve being quite desirable at DL. It’s just a completely different mindset with the company staffing numbers and willingness to pay premium. DL RSVs can make much more than ours and manipulate their schedule as the month goes, which is the biggest benefit to me.

This has significant impacts to LH scheduling as well and is why you can’t just take what you like from one system and swap it out. I’m not advocating one way or the other, but it would take a complete shift on pilots habits as well as the company; limiting 2 PP trips until everyone has a shot and allowing reserves to pick up on days off and get PP as well, which is what they have. I have heard in the past that our union was against reserves picking up on days off as it was seen as manpower negative.

I have a good buddy over there in his 8th year and we talk about this stuff regularly and this is what I’ve put together over the years. I’m not saying it can’t be done but it sounds like it would take a complete rewrite of things and a mentality shift on both sides. Our two systems are just so different from one another.

Edit to add:
Yes to the sick leave thought; DL pilots call in sick after the reserve callout window to ensure it goes to green slip. They don’t have the short notice sick leave comment like we do after 10 AM.
Originally Posted by NuGuy
SC is "you get there when you get there". Don't need people trying to kill themselves to make an artificial deadline. Besides, the traffic in NYC going to one of 3 airports can be vastly different than MSP.
Our language specifically says there will be allowance given for traffic. I once arrived late to a FSB after a 3 hour commute that normally takes 1.5 hours and nothing was ever said to me. My point is that the Delta wording is like the seat belt law. 99% of the time cops won't bother if they see you without a seatbelt, but IF a cop has a proverbial "buur up his/her/its butt" then the words "promptly" allow for open interpretation. Not that I think it would ever be used just there it is. I also think the company has already agreed to making this longer in the new contract. Pre-merger it was 4 hours at legacy UAL if I remember correctly.
Sunvox is offline  
Old 06-21-2023, 12:02 PM
  #28  
Gets Weekends Off
 
LeeFXDWG's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Feb 2006
Position: B737 CAPT IAH
Posts: 1,130
Default

Originally Posted by Sunvox
I was told that the culture at Delta is to accept an extension as a norm. I would say the opposite is true at United especially on domestic flights as it is almost always at the end of a fatiguing situation. If this is not the case, my apologies.



From our contract comparison ALPA page





I should rewrite that line to say "line holders" do not get a lost day off restored at Delta, but United does. I am quoting the ALPA contract comparison guide there so if it is incorrect my apologies.



I took this from a discussion on the ualpilotsforum.info





Our language specifically says there will be allowance given for traffic. I once arrived late to a FSB after a 3 hour commute that normally takes 1.5 hours and nothing was ever said to me. My point is that the Delta wording is like the seat belt law. 99% of the time cops won't bother if they see you without a seatbelt, but IF a cop has a proverbial "buur up his/her/its butt" then the words "promptly" allow for open interpretation. Not that I think it would ever be used just there it is. I also think the company has already agreed to making this longer in the new contract. Pre-merger it was 4 hours at legacy UAL if I remember correctly.
Joe

Stop.

You don’t really understand our UPA as I demonstrated on another forum. The comparison guide is a broad view of both contracts. The devil is always in the details.

I get you are ready for a contract. So am I. That said, stop looking at specific items you think we have better in our current contract. I agree, they do exist. However you need to look at the entire contract to make a true evaluation

WADR,

Lee
LeeFXDWG is offline  
Old 06-21-2023, 03:59 PM
  #29  
Gets Weekends Off
 
LeeFXDWG's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Feb 2006
Position: B737 CAPT IAH
Posts: 1,130
Default

Originally Posted by JTwift
sounds like reserve at DAL can actually make some money if they want. VS us at UAL where it’s tough to actually break guarantee (73), plus our reserve rules sucking hard on top of that.
Our reserve rules suck because the company has free rein unless a legality or strict prohibition of something exists. That is not QWL. That is slavery.

Now can it be approved while staying inside out current model…..absolutely. The NC Position Report had the following info:

Reserve Agreed:
• No involuntary assignment before 10 a.m. on Day 1 of a reserve block
• Elimination of flexible day off (FDOs) for Global categories
• Option to split holy days off (HDOs) into two shorter periods in Global categories • Voluntary Long Call Reserve lines where short call (SC) and field standby (FSB) is only through aggressive pick-up (APU)
• Reserves maintain original scheduled release time when deviating
• Increased restrictions on assigning Visiting Reserves
• All unused Short Call assignments receive 1 hour of additional minimum pay guarantee (MPG)
• Trip trades between reserves
• Reserve day-for-day trades • Add Pay for reserve rolled days off
• Add Pay for late build Short Calls
• Improved release times if unused on last day of reserve • Add Pay for voluntary assignments that start prior to 10 a.m. on Day 1
• Increased pay for voluntary FSB
• Improved voluntary reserve options
• Improved Long Call and Short Call callout times

Open Items:
• Increase in number of reserve days off
• Increase in the daily value of reserve guarantee
• Pilot option to add an additional reserve day in high LPA months
• Short Call caps
• Elimination of FDOs for Basic categories
• Elimination of involuntary FSB
• Remove crew desk discretion from reserve assignment order
• Incentives to avoid involuntarily rolling of reserve days off


If I were king I’d change some of the agreed items like screw 1 hour of MPG for unused SC/FSB. It should be add pay always. Alas, the NC is at work with the plan of attack given to them by a much more competent MEC and MC.
LeeFXDWG is offline  
Old 06-21-2023, 09:14 PM
  #30  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Aug 2021
Posts: 712
Default

Originally Posted by LeeFXDWG
Our reserve rules suck because the company has free rein unless a legality or strict prohibition of something exists. That is not QWL. That is slavery.

Now can it be approved while staying inside out current model…..absolutely. The NC Position Report had the following info:

Reserve Agreed:
• No involuntary assignment before 10 a.m. on Day 1 of a reserve block
• Elimination of flexible day off (FDOs) for Global categories
• Option to split holy days off (HDOs) into two shorter periods in Global categories • Voluntary Long Call Reserve lines where short call (SC) and field standby (FSB) is only through aggressive pick-up (APU)
• Reserves maintain original scheduled release time when deviating
• Increased restrictions on assigning Visiting Reserves
• All unused Short Call assignments receive 1 hour of additional minimum pay guarantee (MPG)
• Trip trades between reserves
• Reserve day-for-day trades • Add Pay for reserve rolled days off
• Add Pay for late build Short Calls
• Improved release times if unused on last day of reserve • Add Pay for voluntary assignments that start prior to 10 a.m. on Day 1
• Increased pay for voluntary FSB
• Improved voluntary reserve options
• Improved Long Call and Short Call callout times

Open Items:
• Increase in number of reserve days off
• Increase in the daily value of reserve guarantee
• Pilot option to add an additional reserve day in high LPA months
• Short Call caps
• Elimination of FDOs for Basic categories
• Elimination of involuntary FSB
• Remove crew desk discretion from reserve assignment order
• Incentives to avoid involuntarily rolling of reserve days off


If I were king I’d change some of the agreed items like screw 1 hour of MPG for unused SC/FSB. It should be add pay always. Alas, the NC is at work with the plan of attack given to them by a much more competent MEC and MC.
rolling into days off should be voluntary and heavily incentive laden if agreed upon . It’s insane that AA and DL have this and we don’t. There’s no reason for company to not roll into days off.

fdo off global fleet will just be changed to an RDO which can then be used as needed. I don’t see how that’s a win. We never had report before 10am that was something company wanted in tumi.
KnightNight is offline  
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Guard Dude
Delta
201720
04-06-2022 07:59 AM
Outof410
Regional
37
08-01-2015 04:31 PM
boost
Hangar Talk
0
06-20-2008 02:55 PM
vagabond
Hangar Talk
16
03-22-2008 10:10 PM

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



Your Privacy Choices