Search

Notices

All women crew at OSH

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 08-01-2019, 03:12 AM
  #61  
New Hire
 
Joined APC: Aug 2019
Posts: 3
Default

Originally Posted by Learflyer
John Carr’s numbers were spot on. You’re missing the point. Of those few women, they’re absolutely getting called first to interview! We all have our own jaw dropping examples at the regionals and elsewhere.
I am sure your anecdotal evidence is totally trumping actual data, mostly becuase you want to believe it, but if they were *called first* and there would be any preferential hiring going on at major airlines, the ratio between male and female cockpit crew would be skewed when compared to female demographics across ATP license holders.

But it's not. It pretty much averages to around 5% on both ends. It's not that hard to understand.
I weep over how low standards have fallen in this industry, given this even needs explanation.
sigrun is offline  
Old 08-01-2019, 03:41 AM
  #62  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,383
Default

Originally Posted by sigrun
I am sure your anecdotal evidence is totally trumping actual data, mostly becuase you want to believe it, but if they were *called first* and there would be any preferential hiring going on at major airlines, the ratio between male and female cockpit crew would be skewed when compared to female demographics across ATP license holders.



But it's not. It pretty much averages to around 5% on both ends. It's not that hard to understand.

I weep over how low standards have fallen in this industry, given this even needs explanation.


It wouldn’t be skewed. There’s *always* going to be more white males. You’re not listening either. If I have a ton of anecdotal examples then a lot of other pilots from a lot of companies do too.
Learflyer is offline  
Old 08-01-2019, 03:47 AM
  #63  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Aug 2013
Posts: 2,159
Default

Originally Posted by navigatro
you see it as an agenda because you see it as a threat to the status quo, perhaps. or what???

I see it as a company responding to a women in aviation event in a reasonable manner.

I don't see the desire to be treated as an equal as an agenda, BTW.
A threat to what?

A career choice is a personal and individual choice. A corporation is not a person. It shouldn't be trying to advantage, help, influence, individual private citizens, regardless of race, sex, sexual orientation, etc. It's a publicly traded company.

I would be interested to know which other major airlines do this sort of thing. We have drag queen day.... I see that as a threat to common sense and family values.

UAL shouldn't be pushing pilots to save money so the corporation can go out and spend it frivolously.

My wife works in a male dominated career. She has no issues interacting with males or females. It was her choice to pursue it and she did it on her own. No corporations helped her or advised her, or anything. She just did it.

There is no threat, real or perceived in females advancing their careers. My issue is with the corporation playing in a game they shouldn't be messing around in. Let people determine their own path, and by their own hard work and merits succeed.

I know too many people who were pushed into something and then didn't like it. Wasted allot of time, which you can't get back and spent allot of their money, and their families' money too.
baseball is offline  
Old 08-01-2019, 04:00 AM
  #64  
Banned
 
Joined APC: Dec 2018
Posts: 648
Default

Originally Posted by baseball
A threat to what?

A career choice is a personal and individual choice. A corporation is not a person. It shouldn't be trying to advantage, help, influence, individual private citizens, regardless of race, sex, sexual orientation, etc. It's a publicly traded company.

I would be interested to know which other major airlines do this sort of thing. We have drag queen day.... I see that as a threat to common sense and family values.

UAL shouldn't be pushing pilots to save money so the corporation can go out and spend it frivolously.

My wife works in a male dominated career. She has no issues interacting with males or females. It was her choice to pursue it and she did it on her own. No corporations helped her or advised her, or anything. She just did it.

There is no threat, real or perceived in females advancing their careers. My issue is with the corporation playing in a game they shouldn't be messing around in. Let people determine their own path, and by their own hard work and merits succeed.

I know too many people who were pushed into something and then didn't like it. Wasted allot of time, which you can't get back and spent allot of their money, and their families' money too.
Can no one on these boards spell "a lot" correctly?!

The whole point of these events is to encourage participation by underrepresented minorities and show that it is possible for women to do these jobs. Study after study has shown that diversity in the workplace is good for a business. It is in your airline's best interest to reach out to these groups to get them to participate. Just like it is in Google's best interest to reach out to high schools to encourage females and minorities to start learning to code.

As far as drag queen day? How on Earth does that hurt your family? I'm sure you could find a safe space somewhere until it's over.

Last edited by ChecklistMonkey; 08-01-2019 at 04:17 AM.
ChecklistMonkey is offline  
Old 08-01-2019, 04:21 AM
  #65  
New Hire
 
Joined APC: Aug 2019
Posts: 3
Default

Originally Posted by Learflyer
It wouldn’t be skewed. There’s *always* going to be more white males.
This is really starting to look embarassing.
I don't know if you are truly incapable or just refusing to understand that simple point.

No one implied what you said in the quote.
Ratio would be skewed when referencing the pool of female ATP license holders, not "male to female" that no one brought up.
Slightly over 5% ATPs are female. Around 5% of pilots hired at majors are female. Thus, your thesis is refuted.
sigrun is offline  
Old 08-01-2019, 04:22 AM
  #66  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Bestglide's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Dec 2013
Position: 756 left...
Posts: 472
Default

Originally Posted by ChecklistMonkey
Can no one on these boards spell "a lot" correctly?!

The whole point of these events is to encourage participation by underrepresented minorities and show that it is possible for women to do these jobs. Study after study has shown that diversity in the workplace is good for a business. It is in your airline's best interest to reach out to these groups to get them to participate. Just like it is in Google's best interest to reach out to high schools to encourage females and minorities to start learning to code.

As far as drag queen day? How on Earth does that hurt your family? I'm sure you could find a safe space somewhere until it's over.
Please take your extreme liberal beliefs to the other forum where group think and hive mentality prevail.
Ohhhh yeah and spell chex 2.
Bestglide is offline  
Old 08-01-2019, 04:49 AM
  #67  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Aug 2013
Posts: 2,159
Default

Originally Posted by ChecklistMonkey
Can no one on these boards spell "a lot" correctly?!

The whole point of these events is to encourage participation by underrepresented minorities and show that it is possible for women to do these jobs. Study after study has shown that diversity in the workplace is good for a business. It is in your airline's best interest to reach out to these groups to get them to participate. Just like it is in Google's best interest to reach out to high schools to encourage females and minorities to start learning to code.

As far as drag queen day? How on Earth does that hurt your family? I'm sure you could find a safe space somewhere until it's over.
Drag Queen day is an embarrassment to anyone and everyone that cares about their corporate image. I would not take my children to such an event, nor would my wife, or daughter go there. We find this sort of thing disgusting. I would think our corporate leadership to be wiser and more prudent than that. very poor choice. It's one thing to go to Key West on Halloween and see this, it's another thing entirely to have your corporation sponsor this and promote it.

Career choices are personal choices. My daughter has the world in front of her. She will likely kick butt in whatever she chooses. She doesn't need to be pushed in any one direction by anyone. I see women doing great things everywhere they go. I haven't seen any recent statistics, but I would bet dollars to donuts women now dominate college and are likely dominating in high school. I recall the last 3 valedictorians from our childrens high school were female.

Females don't need any help. Just stay out of their way. They seem to be doing just find on their own. My daughter in particular is so independent she doesn't like to get advice or counsel from folks. She wants to do it on her own. I guess the male singer who sung "I did it my way" rings true to her.

The last I checked we don't sponsor "Cajun pilots day, or Latino Pilots Day" Probably time to knock off the OBAP stuff, women in aviation stuff, etc. Time to just free our selves from all the BS and start competing for pilots. The internet provides enough information to prospective candidates as well as on possible career paths. Guidance counselors, etc. all are there to support young people as they pursue their careers and education as well as discover their passions and aptitudes.

I am also not a fan of these "zero time" programs that UAL is pushing. You want it, go out and earn it and compete on your own merits.

Every time I hear "turn off the APU" I will think twice about it. Not going to fund this crap. Seriously, a crew, a wide body plane, and 100 employees all on company paid business. What a boondoggle.
baseball is offline  
Old 08-01-2019, 05:58 AM
  #68  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,383
Default

Originally Posted by baseball
Drag Queen day is an embarrassment to anyone and everyone that cares about their corporate image. I would not take my children to such an event, nor would my wife, or daughter go there. We find this sort of thing disgusting. I would think our corporate leadership to be wiser and more prudent than that. very poor choice. It's one thing to go to Key West on Halloween and see this, it's another thing entirely to have your corporation sponsor this and promote it.



Career choices are personal choices. My daughter has the world in front of her. She will likely kick butt in whatever she chooses. She doesn't need to be pushed in any one direction by anyone. I see women doing great things everywhere they go. I haven't seen any recent statistics, but I would bet dollars to donuts women now dominate college and are likely dominating in high school. I recall the last 3 valedictorians from our childrens high school were female.



Females don't need any help. Just stay out of their way. They seem to be doing just find on their own. My daughter in particular is so independent she doesn't like to get advice or counsel from folks. She wants to do it on her own. I guess the male singer who sung "I did it my way" rings true to her.



The last I checked we don't sponsor "Cajun pilots day, or Latino Pilots Day" Probably time to knock off the OBAP stuff, women in aviation stuff, etc. Time to just free our selves from all the BS and start competing for pilots. The internet provides enough information to prospective candidates as well as on possible career paths. Guidance counselors, etc. all are there to support young people as they pursue their careers and education as well as discover their passions and aptitudes.



I am also not a fan of these "zero time" programs that UAL is pushing. You want it, go out and earn it and compete on your own merits.



Every time I hear "turn off the APU" I will think twice about it. Not going to fund this crap. Seriously, a crew, a wide body plane, and 100 employees all on company paid business. What a boondoggle.


Well said. Checklist Monkey and Sigrun take note.
Learflyer is offline  
Old 08-01-2019, 06:02 AM
  #69  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Jul 2013
Posts: 4,752
Default

Nice first post!!!!

You wake up early this morning, and create an alternate account just for that?

Originally Posted by sigrun
Why do you doubt it? UAL actually actively promotes themselves as good workplace for women in aviation. They just appear more attractive than other companies.
I doubt it. All the legacies tout themselves as the most attractive.

Originally Posted by sigrun
also fail to understand how statistics work.
If ~5% of ATP license holder are female (Source: WAI), the average ratio across ALL companies should be around 5%.
While you, for some reason, focus only on UAL.
Well, it's a UAL post in a UAL section, and I'm not so sure your grasp of statistics is that good.

Make to sign in with this account when you flame me and not the other one you usually use...

Originally Posted by ChecklistMonkey
The whole point of these events is to encourage participation by underrepresented minorities and show that it is possible for women to do these jobs.
And as mentioned, it's ALREADY been proven that it's possible. Move on...
John Carr is offline  
Old 08-01-2019, 06:17 AM
  #70  
Banned
 
Joined APC: Dec 2018
Posts: 648
Default

Originally Posted by baseball
Drag Queen day is an embarrassment to anyone and everyone that cares about their corporate image. I would not take my children to such an event, nor would my wife, or daughter go there. We find this sort of thing disgusting. I would think our corporate leadership to be wiser and more prudent than that. very poor choice. It's one thing to go to Key West on Halloween and see this, it's another thing entirely to have your corporation sponsor this and promote it.

Career choices are personal choices. My daughter has the world in front of her. She will likely kick butt in whatever she chooses. She doesn't need to be pushed in any one direction by anyone. I see women doing great things everywhere they go. I haven't seen any recent statistics, but I would bet dollars to donuts women now dominate college and are likely dominating in high school. I recall the last 3 valedictorians from our childrens high school were female.

Females don't need any help. Just stay out of their way. They seem to be doing just find on their own. My daughter in particular is so independent she doesn't like to get advice or counsel from folks. She wants to do it on her own. I guess the male singer who sung "I did it my way" rings true to her.

The last I checked we don't sponsor "Cajun pilots day, or Latino Pilots Day" Probably time to knock off the OBAP stuff, women in aviation stuff, etc. Time to just free our selves from all the BS and start competing for pilots. The internet provides enough information to prospective candidates as well as on possible career paths. Guidance counselors, etc. all are there to support young people as they pursue their careers and education as well as discover their passions and aptitudes.

I am also not a fan of these "zero time" programs that UAL is pushing. You want it, go out and earn it and compete on your own merits.

Every time I hear "turn off the APU" I will think twice about it. Not going to fund this crap. Seriously, a crew, a wide body plane, and 100 employees all on company paid business. What a boondoggle.
Sounds like someone gets offended too easily. I personally think it's disgusting you and your family are so closed minded to things and people that are different than you. It's a shame.

And you to lighten up on being forced. United isn't going to these events and telling girls " be pilots or else!!!" Just like job fairs, career days, junior achievement or military recruiters, it is presenting careers as an option. Corporations partner with underrepresented minority organizations all the time to provide exposure. Unless you have a pilot in your family, you probably have no idea what a career in aviation is like. Uninformed guidance counselors are no help. Take a deep breath. No one is trying to force your daughter at gunpoint to become a United pilot. E
ChecklistMonkey is offline  
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
USN2FEDEX
FedEx
3331
09-04-2019 07:45 PM
Trojan65
Foreign
21
01-27-2017 06:19 PM
DogWhisperer
Delta
2
06-19-2016 12:26 PM
MD11Fr8Dog
Cargo
23
01-16-2011 09:18 AM

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



Your Privacy Choices