Search

Notices

Spirit of NKS

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 01-03-2015, 08:03 PM
  #9311  
Gets Weekends Off
 
gonyon's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Oct 2010
Posts: 1,432
Default

Ask the guys at endeavor about that
gonyon is offline  
Old 01-03-2015, 08:24 PM
  #9312  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Jan 2008
Posts: 246
Default

Originally Posted by Lobaeux
Higher FO pay rates for United, yes, but how about the QOL?
I left Spirit after 8 months to come to UAL.

At Spirit I was on reserve except my last month where I was a line holder. Overall, I have about a year of sitting reserve at UAL and a little over a year as a very junior line holder. From a QOL perspective here is my take on it. Broadly speaking, if you can get the transition conflict to work as a reserve guy at Spirit, you will have more days off. However, if you don't get that transition conflict or when you are actually on reserve, UAL does have better rules overall. We all start out on long call and you can't start (unless you want to) before late in the morning on your day one of reserve blocks as well. Furthermore, the long call system does make it very worthwhile for those who commute to reserve to pick up trips. Yes, we do have 'ready reserve' but those can work in your favor to pick them up, especially if you live in base, pick a ready reserve time between hub banks, as that buries yourself in the reserve order for the rest of your reserve blocks. I have picked up ready reserve times to bury myself to avoid getting called out on a trip. Also, if you have more than two ready reserves or accelerations to short call assignments, you get an additional hour over guarantee if you aren't going to break it for every instance they do that. In about a year of actually sitting reserve here, I had my day rolled once (it actually worked in my favor). L-CAL, yes, they did roll reserve day offs a lot. But with the new system it costs them a lot of money to do it and it is happening a lot less as they fixed a lot of staffing issues that were leading to the rolled days. There are some other nice things in the contract that does make reserve not that bad at UAL from a QOL perspective.

As a line holder, the monthly credits are higher at UAL and days off similar if you can't get the transition conflict. We also have a min day and duty rig that make the trips pretty productive or you will get paid. Basically, if your TAFB is more than 74ish hours the trips will pay 22ish hours at least.

Yes, four days off between trips and the transition conflict language is awesome. Industry leading.

I also like PBS better than a line bidding system. For me, it allows the flexibility to bid specific days off I need up front a lot easier than worrying about getting a line and then trying to trade around with the line improvement windows, etc.

Hope this broke down some specifics about the QOL comparison. Yes, Spirit does have great QOL, but the point I am making is you can have good pay WITH QOL provisions and you all need to go for both next round.

I wish the Spirit guys and gals the best of luck. It wouldn't surprise me if Spirit management offers early in negotiations nice pay rates but with a PBS scheduling system as a pilot negotiation divisional tactic.
Seggy is offline  
Old 01-03-2015, 08:36 PM
  #9313  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Jan 2014
Position: A320 Left
Posts: 715
Default

Originally Posted by Seggy
I left Spirit after 8 months to come to UAL.

At Spirit I was on reserve except my last month where I was a line holder. Overall, I have about a year of sitting reserve at UAL and a little over a year as a very junior line holder. From a QOL perspective here is my take on it. Broadly speaking, if you can get the transition conflict to work as a reserve guy at Spirit, you will have more days off. However, if you don't get that transition conflict or when you are actually on reserve, UAL does have better rules overall. We all start out on long call and you can't start (unless you want to) before late in the morning on your day one of reserve blocks as well. Furthermore, the long call system does make it very worthwhile for those who commute to reserve to pick up trips. Yes, we do have 'ready reserve' but those can work in your favor to pick them up, especially if you live in base, pick a ready reserve time between hub banks, as that buries yourself in the reserve order for the rest of your reserve blocks. I have picked up ready reserve times to bury myself to avoid getting called out on a trip. Also, if you have more than two ready reserves or accelerations to short call assignments, you get an additional hour over guarantee if you aren't going to break it for every instance they do that. In about a year of actually sitting reserve here, I had my day rolled once (it actually worked in my favor). L-CAL, yes, they did roll reserve day offs a lot. But with the new system it costs them a lot of money to do it and it is happening a lot less as they fixed a lot of staffing issues that were leading to the rolled days. There are some other nice things in the contract that does make reserve not that bad at UAL from a QOL perspective.

As a line holder, the monthly credits are higher at UAL and days off similar if you can't get the transition conflict. We also have a min day and duty rig that make the trips pretty productive or you will get paid. Basically, if your TAFB is more than 74ish hours the trips will pay 22ish hours at least.

Yes, four days off between trips and the transition conflict language is awesome. Industry leading.

I also like PBS better than a line bidding system. For me, it allows the flexibility to bid specific days off I need up front a lot easier than worrying about getting a line and then trying to trade around with the line improvement windows, etc.

Hope this broke down some specifics about the QOL comparison. Yes, Spirit does have great QOL, but the point I am making is you can have good pay WITH QOL provisions and you all need to go for both next round.

I wish the Spirit guys and gals the best of luck. It wouldn't surprise me if Spirit management offers early in negotiations nice pay rates but with a PBS scheduling system as a pilot negotiation divisional tactic.
Thanks for the analysis Mark. Fair and balanced!
ManFlex is offline  
Old 01-03-2015, 08:39 PM
  #9314  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Jan 2014
Position: A320 Left
Posts: 715
Default

Originally Posted by gonyon
Ask the guys at endeavor about that
I think having to have 1500 hours TT has a lot more to do with recruiting problems at the regionals/commuters. Regardless, hoping to dissuade pilots from staying at Spirit as a way to gain negotiating leverage is a fool's errand.
ManFlex is offline  
Old 01-03-2015, 08:44 PM
  #9315  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Jan 2008
Posts: 246
Default

Originally Posted by ManFlex
Thanks for the analysis Mark. Fair and balanced!

I really wish you guys luck in the next contract. Spirit isn't a bad place to be, you guys have a pretty good contract, tweak it where it needs that tweaking!
Seggy is offline  
Old 01-03-2015, 09:55 PM
  #9316  
Gets Weekends Off
 
gonyon's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Oct 2010
Posts: 1,432
Default

Originally Posted by ManFlex
I think having to have 1500 hours TT has a lot more to do with recruiting problems at the regionals/commuters. Regardless, hoping to dissuade pilots from staying at Spirit as a way to gain negotiating leverage is a fool's errand.

I hear that they'll hire 30 with 4-5 showing up for class. It's simple, they go to the better paying regional. I think the same can/will happen here if people know what other properties are offering
gonyon is offline  
Old 01-04-2015, 04:34 AM
  #9317  
Banned
 
Joined APC: Jan 2006
Position: A-320
Posts: 6,929
Default

Originally Posted by ManFlex
Thanks for the analysis Mark. Fair and balanced!
Ahhhhhh, that's who it is, Go RU!!!!!!

Excellent point of view Mark, Thanks!
JoeyMeatballs is offline  
Old 01-04-2015, 10:06 AM
  #9318  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Jul 2008
Position: 320 Left soon middle
Posts: 488
Default

I am glad most of you guys are happy here. Most FOs I have been flying with told me they were going to stay. But recently I started to fly with many junior guys again, guys in the 1000 range. Almost all who were less than 40 years old had applications at AA, UAL, DAL, and some at UPS and FEDEX. They are not unhappy here, but they would rather be at a legacy. I can totally understand them.

When I came over from a regional I was very happy. Compared to that this was awesome. But the novelty does wear off rather fast and after you upgrade things start to become really annoying on certain days.

Like my last trip. I walk into an absolutely filthy cockpit at midnight for my red eye transcon flight. Every cockpit is filthy at Spirit unless it is a brand new plane. When I say filthy, I mean it.

The crew is gone, but the plane has several MX items that were not reported. Never mind they came from an MX base.

On a side note: I see this all the time. Some CAs even brief me: "Hey this is this but it is not in the book". These are guys I have never met before. Well I am glad people out there still have faith in humanity because for all they know I could be the largest a hole and call the CP. Some CAs do that here. Good old S.A. the local FLL favorite just to mention one.

... But this night my FO is sharp and he catches everything. It all goes into the book and we take an 1h+ delay. One hour delay for two minor items. Tops 10 min fix in DTW. Not so in LAX. Thanks guys!

This is all not a big deal because at Spirit you learn how to manage your sleep cycle so an extra hour for this red eye is nothing. My new (and happy to be here) FO is already yawning and we have not even pushed. He said he had a great layover, he saw the Queen Marry and the Russian sub in the afternoon. Ouch... that will hurt. I am glad I gave him the LAX leg

I go back to my duties. Now I have time to do everything properly. This delay is really a win win situation I just don't have a good attitude anymore. At Spirit we got some additional preflight items to take care of. For example you get to do some origami with the paperwork because due to a software error some printers still don't recognize page brakes. Once I am done tearing all the paperwork into peaces I have to reference some existing DMIs in our brand new MEL! It is about 10-15 lbs now. It is in a gigantic binder. Spirit has miniaturization backwards. It is THE largest MEL I have ever seen in my career. If the Space Shuttle has an MEL, I bet it is smaller than ours. Meanwhile I can't download the PDF version (not that it is approved for use) because our IT department does not support my apple devices. They are hardcore droid guys over there. But that is OK because iPads are coming! They have been coming for 4-5 years now. Next, my 55+ very friendly senior FLL lead wants ice and catering but we don't cater this flight. Why would we? It is only 5h block and we are loosing money on catering. The MX items get addressed fast but we end up waiting 30 min for an amendment. That is because MX, Dispatch, and Crew Scheduling do not communicate with each other even though they are all sitting in the same room. It is either that or the roach coach must have pulled into the parking lot at Miramar.

May be 5-6 years ago I would have written an e-mail to the CP about the dirty cockpit, about the 30 min wait for an amendment, and about all the other things that I did not care to mention in my rant. But our CP does not return phone calls or e-mails. Some assistant CPs do, but it is not 5-6 years ago so I do not care to write anything except this rant on this forum.

So back to the topic... working here is fun for a while. The place is getting better. It is much better than 7-8 years ago. But it will never be a legacy. It has no culture and it will never have one except perhaps the culture of Walmart. I am too old and have too much seniority that I just can't throw away. I wish I would be 30-35. I would be gone so fast if AA or UAL would call. Not that I am their top candidate but assuming they would want me over there I would leave. Just before posting this I just looked at AA's job page... MIA is junior. But I just can't do it. Too expensive. I will not see the return.

Even two years ago I was arguing that Spirit will not have an exodus of pilots. But now that we are in the 1000 range, I think this will change. With the raises all the legacies are getting even a 3rd 4th year CA will make the switch as long he or she is relatively young. Yes we do have QOL and yes pay will get better but who knows what QOL and pay will be exactly in the next contract? I don't. It is one in the hand or two in the bush. If you get the call that is. The biggest draw back IMHO is that one who leaves now for a legacy will be sitting on the furlough range for some time. That would be my biggest fear.
Normann is offline  
Old 01-04-2015, 10:27 AM
  #9319  
Banned
 
Joined APC: Jan 2006
Position: A-320
Posts: 6,929
Default

I don't know. I'm 34, #72x and every now and again "think" about applying elsewhere. Not because I want too necessarily,but because a lot of people seem to believe the legacies are like winning the lottery now a days. It very well may be true, I dunno. Sometimes I ask myself why I wanna stay here and for a split second I think maybe I'm settling but then I think about how much im home with my daughter, the time off and schedule flexibility in the summer and the guys I work with and I really don't want to go elsewhere. I want this place to get better and I want more money but I'm not sure leaving here for more money is the right decision. The pay rates are fantastic on the 75/6 over at the legacies but the thought of doing the Atlantic stuff (talk about red eyes) makes me ill, lol.

Anyway, if the next contract is a big disappoint I'll still have 30 years left to go chase that legacy job.......

Of course the time off, schedule flexibility and crews at the legacies are great as well and will probably get better but if I'm going there to chase the money I'd probably always chase the bigger airplane and not be home as much, unfortunately there really isn't an easy answer.
JoeyMeatballs is offline  
Old 01-04-2015, 11:12 AM
  #9320  
Gets Weekends Off
 
gonyon's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Oct 2010
Posts: 1,432
Default Spirit of NKS

Originally Posted by Normann
I am glad most of you guys are happy here. Most FOs I have been flying with told me they were going to stay. But recently I started to fly with many junior guys again, guys in the 1000 range. Almost all who were less than 40 years old had applications at AA, UAL, DAL, and some at UPS and FEDEX. They are not unhappy here, but they would rather be at a legacy. I can totally understand them.



When I came over from a regional I was very happy. Compared to that this was awesome. But the novelty does wear off rather fast and after you upgrade things start to become really annoying on certain days.



Like my last trip. I walk into an absolutely filthy cockpit at midnight for my red eye transcon flight. Every cockpit is filthy at Spirit unless it is a brand new plane. When I say filthy, I mean it.



The crew is gone, but the plane has several MX items that were not reported. Never mind they came from an MX base.



On a side note: I see this all the time. Some CAs even brief me: "Hey this is this but it is not in the book". These are guys I have never met before. Well I am glad people out there still have faith in humanity because for all they know I could be the largest a hole and call the CP. Some CAs do that here. Good old S.A. the local FLL favorite just to mention one.



... But this night my FO is sharp and he catches everything. It all goes into the book and we take an 1h+ delay. One hour delay for two minor items. Tops 10 min fix in DTW. Not so in LAX. Thanks guys!



This is all not a big deal because at Spirit you learn how to manage your sleep cycle so an extra hour for this red eye is nothing. My new (and happy to be here) FO is already yawning and we have not even pushed. He said he had a great layover, he saw the Queen Marry and the Russian sub in the afternoon. Ouch... that will hurt. I am glad I gave him the LAX leg



I go back to my duties. Now I have time to do everything properly. This delay is really a win win situation I just don't have a good attitude anymore. At Spirit we got some additional preflight items to take care of. For example you get to do some origami with the paperwork because due to a software error some printers still don't recognize page brakes. Once I am done tearing all the paperwork into peaces I have to reference some existing DMIs in our brand new MEL! It is about 10-15 lbs now. It is in a gigantic binder. Spirit has miniaturization backwards. It is THE largest MEL I have ever seen in my career. If the Space Shuttle has an MEL, I bet it is smaller than ours. Meanwhile I can't download the PDF version (not that it is approved for use) because our IT department does not support my apple devices. They are hardcore droid guys over there. But that is OK because iPads are coming! They have been coming for 4-5 years now. Next, my 55+ very friendly senior FLL lead wants ice and catering but we don't cater this flight. Why would we? It is only 5h block and we are loosing money on catering. The MX items get addressed fast but we end up waiting 30 min for an amendment. That is because MX, Dispatch, and Crew Scheduling do not communicate with each other even though they are all sitting in the same room. It is either that or the roach coach must have pulled into the parking lot at Miramar.



May be 5-6 years ago I would have written an e-mail to the CP about the dirty cockpit, about the 30 min wait for an amendment, and about all the other things that I did not care to mention in my rant. But our CP does not return phone calls or e-mails. Some assistant CPs do, but it is not 5-6 years ago so I do not care to write anything except this rant on this forum.



So back to the topic... working here is fun for a while. The place is getting better. It is much better than 7-8 years ago. But it will never be a legacy. It has no culture and it will never have one except perhaps the culture of Walmart. I am too old and have too much seniority that I just can't throw away. I wish I would be 30-35. I would be gone so fast if AA or UAL would call. Not that I am their top candidate but assuming they would want me over there I would leave. Just before posting this I just looked at AA's job page... MIA is junior. But I just can't do it. Too expensive. I will not see the return.



Even two years ago I was arguing that Spirit will not have an exodus of pilots. But now that we are in the 1000 range, I think this will change. With the raises all the legacies are getting even a 3rd 4th year CA will make the switch as long he or she is relatively young. Yes we do have QOL and yes pay will get better but who knows what QOL and pay will be exactly in the next contract? I don't. It is one in the hand or two in the bush. If you get the call that is. The biggest draw back IMHO is that one who leaves now for a legacy will be sitting on the furlough range for some time. That would be my biggest fear.

This is an excellent analysis of the current situation. It might get a lot better here, it might not. What you have at the legacies is s known Whatever might have here is a giant "?" For now I'm going to take the risk and see what happens because I am at an age where upgrading at a legacy may not be a good choice. Who wants to sit reserve in Ewr/lga/jfk in your fifties? So I'm in no big hurry
gonyon is offline  
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
cs757200
Major
11
08-27-2011 11:55 AM
Splanky
Major
7
05-16-2009 06:13 PM
shiftwork
Major
440
03-18-2009 05:05 PM
DWN3GRN
Major
16
09-02-2008 04:11 PM
A320Flyer
Major
5
09-02-2008 04:05 AM

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



Your Privacy Choices