ALPA: "Don't blame us!"
#61
So you just grinned and bore it like a good soldier? You just paid your dues? The dues aren't getting any easier. The price for a right seat job at mainline is much higher than at any other point in history - for MOST people.
#62
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Jul 2008
Position: Left
Posts: 1,809
I don't come on here and complain about wages but........
The argument on this thread was started by a mainline pilot yelling at us for taking his job. We just went with it.
Like I said a couple posts ago, Other than the military, the regionals have become pretty much the only reliable way to get to that mainline position. This essentially forces us to accept those wages if we want a lucrative career. This is due to scope relaxation in the previous decade.
So yes we are 50% of the problem but it is not a problem that was caused by us.
#63
"Earth to Dutch1"
So, in your counterfactual, if ALPA contracts in bankruptcy hadn't allowed scope changes that permitted RJs, thousands of 250 hour wet comercial pilots would now be mainline pilots? That all those RJ pilots hired since 2001 would have just hired at DL, NW, UA, and like? You need a history lesson. And ECON 101.
Gf
So, in your counterfactual, if ALPA contracts in bankruptcy hadn't allowed scope changes that permitted RJs, thousands of 250 hour wet comercial pilots would now be mainline pilots? That all those RJ pilots hired since 2001 would have just hired at DL, NW, UA, and like? You need a history lesson. And ECON 101.
Gf
#64
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Jun 2010
Position: Just another RJ guy
Posts: 906
A hell of a lot. Those attorneys, financial analysts, benefits specialists, etc. aren't cheap, and your MEC doesn't pay for any of them. It's all paid for out of the national budget, subsidized by the big carriers.
Of course there's a benefit to us! When regional carriers are underpaid, it puts downward pressure on our own contracts. Doing what we can to bring up the standards at the regionals benefits our own negotiations. Of course, the current head honcho doesn't seem to understand this, but previous ones have.
Of course there's a benefit to us! When regional carriers are underpaid, it puts downward pressure on our own contracts. Doing what we can to bring up the standards at the regionals benefits our own negotiations. Of course, the current head honcho doesn't seem to understand this, but previous ones have.
ALPA National did more harm than anything with the ASA/XJet agreement. They wasted TONS of money, resources and, time on pure crap. Another reason ALPA National is a giant joke. Keep your ALPA...we need our own regional union. One that can fight for us...not "settle" because sometimes we need to take what's given to us.
National's attorneys, financial specialists, and benefits specialists did NOTHING to help anyone in the ASA/Xjet agreement. I can't believe you're making an argument that they did so much to help. I just don't get it...simply baffled .
Last edited by AlaskaBound; 01-24-2014 at 04:04 PM. Reason: Editttt
#65
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Jun 2010
Position: Just another RJ guy
Posts: 906
I suppose when you were a regional pilot the major airline pilots weren't throwing insults in your face and telling you you were the problem with the airline path of progression. I'm sure you didn't scream at mainline guys because they probably weren't screaming at you telling you you were the problem. Times have changed and it's hardly fair to compare. And just because things were crap then doesn't mean things have to stay the same. We need to stand up and make a change. Why settle? We don't have to be like the generation before us.
#66
So you're basically bragging, and admitting, that ALPA national spent a hellovalot of money to come up with, and support, an offensive crap sandwich of an agreement (TA). Talk about being out of touch.
ALPA National did more harm than anything with the ASA/XJet agreement. They wasted TONS of money, resources and, time on pure crap. Another reason ALPA National is a giant joke. Keep your ALPA...we need our own regional union. One that can fight for us...not "settle" because sometimes we need to take what's given to us.
National's attorneys, financial specialists, and benefits specialists did NOTHING to help anyone in the ASA/Xjet agreement. I can't believe you're making an argument that they did so much to help. I just don't get it...simply baffled .
ALPA National did more harm than anything with the ASA/XJet agreement. They wasted TONS of money, resources and, time on pure crap. Another reason ALPA National is a giant joke. Keep your ALPA...we need our own regional union. One that can fight for us...not "settle" because sometimes we need to take what's given to us.
National's attorneys, financial specialists, and benefits specialists did NOTHING to help anyone in the ASA/Xjet agreement. I can't believe you're making an argument that they did so much to help. I just don't get it...simply baffled .
And for the record, I'd have voted against that POS contract, too. I just know better than to blame ALPA for it. Just like I don't blame ALPA for the craptastic SLI at my airline.
#67
Moderator
Joined APC: Oct 2006
Position: B757/767
Posts: 13,088
This is a more controlled response at least.
I don't come on here and complain about wages but........
The argument on this thread was started by a mainline pilot yelling at us for taking his job. We just went with it.
Like I said a couple posts ago, Other than the military, the regionals have become pretty much the only reliable way to get to that mainline position. This essentially forces us to accept those wages if we want a lucrative career. This is due to scope relaxation in the previous decade.
So yes we are 50% of the problem but it is not a problem that was caused by us.
I don't come on here and complain about wages but........
The argument on this thread was started by a mainline pilot yelling at us for taking his job. We just went with it.
Like I said a couple posts ago, Other than the military, the regionals have become pretty much the only reliable way to get to that mainline position. This essentially forces us to accept those wages if we want a lucrative career. This is due to scope relaxation in the previous decade.
So yes we are 50% of the problem but it is not a problem that was caused by us.
I don't disagree. And to be clear I never said regionals guys were to take all the blame. But as a post 9/11 regional guy myself, I do feel regional guys are partly responsible. More of my feelings are expressed above.
#68
Moderator
Joined APC: Oct 2006
Position: B757/767
Posts: 13,088
I suppose when you were a regional pilot the major airline pilots weren't throwing insults in your face and telling you you were the problem with the airline path of progression. I'm sure you didn't scream at mainline guys because they probably weren't screaming at you telling you you were the problem. Times have changed and it's hardly fair to compare. And just because things were crap then doesn't mean things have to stay the same. We need to stand up and make a change. Why settle? We don't have to be like the generation before us.
#69
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Jun 2010
Position: Just another RJ guy
Posts: 906
You're baffled because you don't understand the difference between what national does and what your local MEC does. National provides the resources. But you local leaders make the decisions. You don't think the guys at national are baffled by idiotic decisions at local MECs? Happens all the time. But it's not national's job to step in and tell individual pilot groups what to do. It's national's job to just provide the resources and let the local guys decide what they want to do. Even if it doesn't make much sense.
And for the record, I'd have voted against that POS contract, too. I just know better than to blame ALPA for it. Just like I don't blame ALPA for the craptastic SLI at my airline.
And for the record, I'd have voted against that POS contract, too. I just know better than to blame ALPA for it. Just like I don't blame ALPA for the craptastic SLI at my airline.
And the Endeavor seniority list was a result of arbitration because there was no way the 3 carriers were going to agree to an ISL. Just assuming you were or are with 9E since you go by PCL. Ya can't blame ALPA for binding arbitration.
#70
Moderator
Joined APC: Oct 2006
Position: B757/767
Posts: 13,088
Anyone that believes National doesn't have any influence, pull or say in the local MECs is naive. The politics within the ALPA leadership, local along with national, are deeply intertwined. Local MECs take direction from national. If national is going to spend TONS of money on local MECs affairs you better believe they will have a say as to what happens or what the local MEC does. You put WAY too much faith in National and their intentions.
And the Endeavor seniority list was a result of arbitration because there was no way the 3 carriers were going to agree to an ISL. Just assuming you were or are with 9E since you go by PCL. Ya can't blame ALPA for binding arbitration.
And the Endeavor seniority list was a result of arbitration because there was no way the 3 carriers were going to agree to an ISL. Just assuming you were or are with 9E since you go by PCL. Ya can't blame ALPA for binding arbitration.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post