Mesa Pilots - Why the Bad Rap? Warranted?
#31
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Oct 2014
Posts: 628
![Default](https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Here is my additional thoughts:
1. For a Houston area pilot, there isn’t a better regional that doesn’t involved a commute. ExpressJet with their 9 year upgrade? SkyWest with their commute to ORD or DTW and then a transfer back after a year to sit on reserve? Then, 10 years before you can get back to IAH as a CA?
2. Some of our CA’s are crediting over 200 hours per month. Exceeding the pay at other regionals.
3. FO’s immediately get a line and can fly 90+ hours per month if they want to.
![](https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/clear.gif)
#32
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Mar 2016
Posts: 122
![Default](https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Don't you want to have some pride in the company you work for? There is absolutely no other reason to go to Mesa except for a Houston base. I've been in the regional recruiting world and I have seen many pilots with 5 or 6 plus checkride failures get hired at Mesa. As one post mentioned, DWI's? Go to Mesa. Failed out of 121 programs? Go to Mesa. And no, not all regionals have this practice. It's a dangerous practice. Just because you can force someone through training with 10 extra SIM sessions and 80 plus hours of IOE, doesn't make them a safe or professional pilot. It's a disgrace to our profession and hurts the entire industry. Have some respect for yourself and the industry. Go somewhere else.
#33
![Default](https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Spoken by another pilot that knows nothing about Mesa except how to get a jump-seat on our airplanes. Just another troll.
Here is where a pilot at Mesa agrees with your observations:
1. If you are married with kids and need to rely on our health benefits, seriously consider someplace else.
2. $36 per hour for FO’s is pretty pitiful given where the industry is headed.
3. Mesa does seem to give guys a second chance when they come from another airline’s training program. (One of the reasons I think a few of our guys don’t end up at the majors).
Here is what is completely incorrect (at least on the Ejet in IAH):
1. As an FO, my schedule is great. Min Credit. Weekends and Christmas off. Schedules only suck where we are seriously short staffed. Right now, that is Ejet CA’s. (Which they are trying to remedy.) We have no reserve unless you want reserve or missed the deadline for bidding.
2. There is no other regional with a faster upgrade on the Ejet.
3. No one really has a clue financially how Mesa is doing. It is a private company.
4. There are no statistics about individual regionals and where they lose pilots to, unless the regional puts the statistics together.
Here is my additional thoughts:
1. For a Houston area pilot, there isn’t a better regional that doesn’t involved a commute. ExpressJet with their 9 year upgrade? SkyWest with their commute to ORD or DTW and then a transfer back after a year to sit on reserve? Then, 10 years before you can get back to IAH as a CA?
2. Some of our CA’s are crediting over 200 hours per month. Exceeding the pay at other regionals.
3. FO’s immediately get a line and can fly 90+ hours per month if they want to.
Here is where a pilot at Mesa agrees with your observations:
1. If you are married with kids and need to rely on our health benefits, seriously consider someplace else.
2. $36 per hour for FO’s is pretty pitiful given where the industry is headed.
3. Mesa does seem to give guys a second chance when they come from another airline’s training program. (One of the reasons I think a few of our guys don’t end up at the majors).
Here is what is completely incorrect (at least on the Ejet in IAH):
1. As an FO, my schedule is great. Min Credit. Weekends and Christmas off. Schedules only suck where we are seriously short staffed. Right now, that is Ejet CA’s. (Which they are trying to remedy.) We have no reserve unless you want reserve or missed the deadline for bidding.
2. There is no other regional with a faster upgrade on the Ejet.
3. No one really has a clue financially how Mesa is doing. It is a private company.
4. There are no statistics about individual regionals and where they lose pilots to, unless the regional puts the statistics together.
Here is my additional thoughts:
1. For a Houston area pilot, there isn’t a better regional that doesn’t involved a commute. ExpressJet with their 9 year upgrade? SkyWest with their commute to ORD or DTW and then a transfer back after a year to sit on reserve? Then, 10 years before you can get back to IAH as a CA?
2. Some of our CA’s are crediting over 200 hours per month. Exceeding the pay at other regionals.
3. FO’s immediately get a line and can fly 90+ hours per month if they want to.
#34
Line Holder
Joined APC: Dec 2015
Position: Captain
Posts: 72
![Default](https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I think the fact that you can call a 121 airline and be hired over the phone and put in class within a week or two answers the OP's question.
Don't you want to have some pride in the company you work for? There is absolutely no other reason to go to Mesa except for a Houston base. I've been in the regional recruiting world and I have seen many pilots with 5 or 6 plus checkride failures get hired at Mesa. As one post mentioned, DWI's? Go to Mesa. Failed out of 121 programs? Go to Mesa. And no, not all regionals have this practice. It's a dangerous practice. Just because you can force someone through training with 10 extra SIM sessions and 80 plus hours of IOE, doesn't make them a safe or professional pilot. It's a disgrace to our profession and hurts the entire industry. Have some respect for yourself and the industry. Go somewhere else.
Don't you want to have some pride in the company you work for? There is absolutely no other reason to go to Mesa except for a Houston base. I've been in the regional recruiting world and I have seen many pilots with 5 or 6 plus checkride failures get hired at Mesa. As one post mentioned, DWI's? Go to Mesa. Failed out of 121 programs? Go to Mesa. And no, not all regionals have this practice. It's a dangerous practice. Just because you can force someone through training with 10 extra SIM sessions and 80 plus hours of IOE, doesn't make them a safe or professional pilot. It's a disgrace to our profession and hurts the entire industry. Have some respect for yourself and the industry. Go somewhere else.
#35
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: May 2017
Posts: 2,145
![Default](https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Honestly, and it may not be readily apparent to yourself and other Mesa pilots, but many of you seem to have a real case of Stockholm syndrome. WHY on earth would you encourage others to come commiserate and work with you at one of the worst regionals out there? More pilots only means it takes longer for you and your pilot group to see any real gains. So much of your rebuttal sounds like rubbish excuses.
#36
![Default](https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I mean its actually pretty simple... Pilots dont like Mesa and don’t understand why pilots agree to work there considering:
1) Absolutely the worst health insurance in the industry. I looked at my friend’s plan (Mesa CA) and it is truly garbage.
2) Subpar pay and work rules. I know Mesa recently upped some of their compensation but it still doesn’t touch most of the other regionals.
3) It is true that many pilots who fail out of other airline training programs end up at Mesa. 2 of the pilots who failed out of my initial are now Mesa pilots.
4) The schedules are pretty terrible and you do not have any scheduling flexibility. Mesa will continue to try and staff their flying on reduced aircraft manning. As other regionals raise the bar to attract new pilots to their ranks, Mesa will keep trying to operate the aircraft it has with fewer and fewer pilots which means very few days off and an inability to swap trips.
5) There are other regionals with much quicker upgrade and much better career progression that are hiring like gangbusters right now.
6) With Endeavor now offering not only vastly superior compensation and work rules but also a positive space ticket to base if you miss your first flight, the commuting thing is super easy. Not to mention the AA WOs offer their pilots parity with mainline pilots for boarding priority on any AA branded flight.
7) Being a contract carrier and specifically one that puts itself between a, “rock and a hard place” when it comes to being able to attract pilots and stay profitable Mesa is more at risk than other regionals for losing its flying over the next few years.
8) There are statistics published about what legacy airlines the regional airlines lose pilots to. Mesa doesn’t send nearly as many pilots to mainline legacy carriers as other regional airlines.
1) Absolutely the worst health insurance in the industry. I looked at my friend’s plan (Mesa CA) and it is truly garbage.
2) Subpar pay and work rules. I know Mesa recently upped some of their compensation but it still doesn’t touch most of the other regionals.
3) It is true that many pilots who fail out of other airline training programs end up at Mesa. 2 of the pilots who failed out of my initial are now Mesa pilots.
4) The schedules are pretty terrible and you do not have any scheduling flexibility. Mesa will continue to try and staff their flying on reduced aircraft manning. As other regionals raise the bar to attract new pilots to their ranks, Mesa will keep trying to operate the aircraft it has with fewer and fewer pilots which means very few days off and an inability to swap trips.
5) There are other regionals with much quicker upgrade and much better career progression that are hiring like gangbusters right now.
6) With Endeavor now offering not only vastly superior compensation and work rules but also a positive space ticket to base if you miss your first flight, the commuting thing is super easy. Not to mention the AA WOs offer their pilots parity with mainline pilots for boarding priority on any AA branded flight.
7) Being a contract carrier and specifically one that puts itself between a, “rock and a hard place” when it comes to being able to attract pilots and stay profitable Mesa is more at risk than other regionals for losing its flying over the next few years.
8) There are statistics published about what legacy airlines the regional airlines lose pilots to. Mesa doesn’t send nearly as many pilots to mainline legacy carriers as other regional airlines.
You want to compete with wholly owneds? Mesa is doing exactly what it needs to do to compete. I don't care who comes thru the door as long the company stays afloat and I don't get violated.
#37
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: May 2017
Posts: 2,145
![Default](https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/images/icons/icon1.gif)
There is no other regional in Houston that can get me to Captain the fastest. I cannot afford FO pay for a family of 4 for how many years at Express Jet. Everyone on here says steer away from commuting if possible to give you the best QOL. As for my record, I’m squeeeky clean.
ExpressJet and SkyWest at IAH are just bad news.
#38
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Aug 2017
Posts: 129
![Default](https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Nobody else has as much as acknowledged your post, but I have to say that I appreciate all of the research that you did!
This thread has a lot of new guys who really don't have the background knowledge to comment, so I appreciate this post with its eye towards historical context. Because sure, the training department is fine, but we would be remiss to ignore the rich and sordid history of Mesa Air Group's unethical treatment of mainline partners and employees over the last few decades.
Since the early days of Larry Risley, the airline had a reputation for being stingy and low paying. It grew to prominence through a series of mergers and acquisitions that began in earnest during the 1980's. Some of those acquired airlines were casualties of the process and thoroughly gutted after getting bought for cents on the dollar (Aspen Airways).
As it grew, management had numerous pilot groups to deal with that were quickly unionizing. This was remedied in 2002 by the creation of Freedom. What was Freedom?
Mesa Air Group has also been a proud participant in numerous lawsuits, including getting sued by United 1997 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mesa_A...ited_codeshare), by Aloha and Hawaiian in 2006 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mesa_A...lated_lawsuits), and oddly enough trying to sue Delta, in Atlanta, around 2008 (MESA AIR GROUP INC v. DELTA AIR LINES INC | FindLaw). More recently, our union sued the company as well.
My favorite was the Aloha lawsuit. Essentially Mesa looked at its books for the purposes of investment or acquisition when the airline wasn't doing well. After saying "No thanks," the company turned around and illegally used that information to compete in Hawaii on the same routes, effectively killing Aloha. They successfully sued us for tens of millions of dollars, but not before we lost the same or more flying CRJ's at a loss around Hawaii.
Shenzen Airlines is another fun one. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mesa_A...npeng_Airlines We had a big falling out with a Chinese airline after trying to create a local joint venture with it. The wanted nothing to do with us after the fact.
Following all these shenanigans, Mesa was the object of a Congressional inquiry and heavily reorganized by a bankruptcy court. They found our CEO contracted with and outsourced to a lot of his own companies, and Mesa paid those companies handsomely for their services. Ask around about the Del Rio, the shady hotel he owned and put crews in. The bankruptcy court put a stop to all that, but many rumors exist on how he faced no legal prosecution. Earlier, he actually fled the country after illegal dealings on Wall Street. That's how he went to the UK for several years and got to be "good buddies" with Richard Branson. Supposedly his lawyer eventually reached a plea deal in which he could return with no jail time.
There is also an extensive history of mistreatment of employees. The company has always stalled negotiations as long as possible, and we were in negotiations for this recent TA for seven years. The only company I know that went longer was Republic, I think their management held out for eight.
Even after reaching a contract, the company fights tooth and nail to readjust the meaning of plain English. My favorite example of this was when we went into arbitration over 50-seat base pay. The company was paying pilots the far lower CRJ-200 rates for sick time, vacation, training, etc. While the contract never specified how that time would be paid, our union reasonably argued that there is only one spare CRJ-200 on property, and our 100+ other aircraft were all in the 76 seat range. It stands to reason we should be paid what nearly every aircraft on property reflects, and what we're normally paid for flying duties.
The story goes that they took a current PHX Captain who hated flying the line and had been part of those negotiations on the union's side, offered him a cushy desk job to say the understanding at the time favored the company's present position, and he did just that. The kicker is after it was all done, they sent him back to the line.
As our seniority list dwindled the last two years amidst stalled negotiations, low pay, and crew mistreatment, there were concerns raised about the caliber of pilot coming to the company. Why would anyone come here when they could make two or three times as much at almost any other regional? It became apparent we were getting the unwanted pilots who couldn't get hired anywhere else. People with DUI's, constant checkride busts, accidents, personality deficiencies, and various other skeletons. Many couldn't hack it at other regionals. There were (are) also the second career types who've just dinked around in Cessnas the last 30 years and want to fly a big boy jet; many of them haven't done the stereotype surrounding them any favors.
These people aren't everyone here, but they do exist, and in numbers far exceeding what most are comfortable with. Now Mesa pilots have a reputation of being low quality, and some legitimately worry about their prospects of getting hired anywhere besides Spirit.
None of this even begins to address the day to day grind of dealing with crew tracking, their attempts to junior assign you, shoddy maintenance, less days off, lower pay, bad hotels, and so much more. But hey, if you're not concerned about any of this, come give Mesa a try!
(Seriously, go through some old threads. The anti-Mesa sentiment is alive and well in threads over a decade old on this website)
Since the early days of Larry Risley, the airline had a reputation for being stingy and low paying. It grew to prominence through a series of mergers and acquisitions that began in earnest during the 1980's. Some of those acquired airlines were casualties of the process and thoroughly gutted after getting bought for cents on the dollar (Aspen Airways).
As it grew, management had numerous pilot groups to deal with that were quickly unionizing. This was remedied in 2002 by the creation of Freedom. What was Freedom?
Mesa Air Group has also been a proud participant in numerous lawsuits, including getting sued by United 1997 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mesa_A...ited_codeshare), by Aloha and Hawaiian in 2006 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mesa_A...lated_lawsuits), and oddly enough trying to sue Delta, in Atlanta, around 2008 (MESA AIR GROUP INC v. DELTA AIR LINES INC | FindLaw). More recently, our union sued the company as well.
My favorite was the Aloha lawsuit. Essentially Mesa looked at its books for the purposes of investment or acquisition when the airline wasn't doing well. After saying "No thanks," the company turned around and illegally used that information to compete in Hawaii on the same routes, effectively killing Aloha. They successfully sued us for tens of millions of dollars, but not before we lost the same or more flying CRJ's at a loss around Hawaii.
Shenzen Airlines is another fun one. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mesa_A...npeng_Airlines We had a big falling out with a Chinese airline after trying to create a local joint venture with it. The wanted nothing to do with us after the fact.
Following all these shenanigans, Mesa was the object of a Congressional inquiry and heavily reorganized by a bankruptcy court. They found our CEO contracted with and outsourced to a lot of his own companies, and Mesa paid those companies handsomely for their services. Ask around about the Del Rio, the shady hotel he owned and put crews in. The bankruptcy court put a stop to all that, but many rumors exist on how he faced no legal prosecution. Earlier, he actually fled the country after illegal dealings on Wall Street. That's how he went to the UK for several years and got to be "good buddies" with Richard Branson. Supposedly his lawyer eventually reached a plea deal in which he could return with no jail time.
There is also an extensive history of mistreatment of employees. The company has always stalled negotiations as long as possible, and we were in negotiations for this recent TA for seven years. The only company I know that went longer was Republic, I think their management held out for eight.
Even after reaching a contract, the company fights tooth and nail to readjust the meaning of plain English. My favorite example of this was when we went into arbitration over 50-seat base pay. The company was paying pilots the far lower CRJ-200 rates for sick time, vacation, training, etc. While the contract never specified how that time would be paid, our union reasonably argued that there is only one spare CRJ-200 on property, and our 100+ other aircraft were all in the 76 seat range. It stands to reason we should be paid what nearly every aircraft on property reflects, and what we're normally paid for flying duties.
The story goes that they took a current PHX Captain who hated flying the line and had been part of those negotiations on the union's side, offered him a cushy desk job to say the understanding at the time favored the company's present position, and he did just that. The kicker is after it was all done, they sent him back to the line.
As our seniority list dwindled the last two years amidst stalled negotiations, low pay, and crew mistreatment, there were concerns raised about the caliber of pilot coming to the company. Why would anyone come here when they could make two or three times as much at almost any other regional? It became apparent we were getting the unwanted pilots who couldn't get hired anywhere else. People with DUI's, constant checkride busts, accidents, personality deficiencies, and various other skeletons. Many couldn't hack it at other regionals. There were (are) also the second career types who've just dinked around in Cessnas the last 30 years and want to fly a big boy jet; many of them haven't done the stereotype surrounding them any favors.
These people aren't everyone here, but they do exist, and in numbers far exceeding what most are comfortable with. Now Mesa pilots have a reputation of being low quality, and some legitimately worry about their prospects of getting hired anywhere besides Spirit.
None of this even begins to address the day to day grind of dealing with crew tracking, their attempts to junior assign you, shoddy maintenance, less days off, lower pay, bad hotels, and so much more. But hey, if you're not concerned about any of this, come give Mesa a try!
(Seriously, go through some old threads. The anti-Mesa sentiment is alive and well in threads over a decade old on this website)
#39
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: May 2017
Posts: 2,145
![Default](https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Everyone shares his concerns regarding the quality of pilots.
The number of pilots going to Southwest indicates that there are those who do make it out.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post