Delta Pilots Association
#281
:-)
Joined APC: Feb 2007
Posts: 7,339
From what I have seen, ALPA will do whatever it takes to avoid a regional - mainline merger scenario. America West/US Airways is the reason why. ALPA would be immediately wiped off the property.
#282
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Jan 2008
Position: Bebe Bus De L'Air Assistant Aerial Conveyance Facilitator
Posts: 351
This is where I disagree. If you ask 100 RJ pilots, 99 will say that they hope that RJ's shrink and mainline grows. Look at their contracts, their jobs really are much worse than ours, they all want to go to mainline.
Focusing on RJ growth right now is akin to focusing on the Soviet menace invading western Europe. It's over. Industry consolidation is here. After CAL/UAL get together then AMR will have to make some move. They will all face the same phenomenon as what happened at Delta. A larger carrier will need larger jets. In case you haven't noticed, RJ's are falling away like flies. They are undergoing massive consolidation now, (probably forced by their parent carriers) because the ones that don't consolidate will die. Comair is shrinking by half and we are hiring. Delta's RJ capacity shrunk 4.4% last quarter and will probably be more than that this quarter.
So if you want to change unions because of the RJ menace, you need to invent a time machine and go back to the 1990's because you are 20 years too late. That problem is over. If you have other reasons to get a new union then discuss that. The dual agenda at National never existed except in webboard warriors minds and even if it did, perestroika has come.
Focusing on RJ growth right now is akin to focusing on the Soviet menace invading western Europe. It's over. Industry consolidation is here. After CAL/UAL get together then AMR will have to make some move. They will all face the same phenomenon as what happened at Delta. A larger carrier will need larger jets. In case you haven't noticed, RJ's are falling away like flies. They are undergoing massive consolidation now, (probably forced by their parent carriers) because the ones that don't consolidate will die. Comair is shrinking by half and we are hiring. Delta's RJ capacity shrunk 4.4% last quarter and will probably be more than that this quarter.
So if you want to change unions because of the RJ menace, you need to invent a time machine and go back to the 1990's because you are 20 years too late. That problem is over. If you have other reasons to get a new union then discuss that. The dual agenda at National never existed except in webboard warriors minds and even if it did, perestroika has come.
The threat isn't 50-seaters. It's the regional lifers who now want to maximize the size of the aircraft they fly and therefore their paycheck, even if it means at the expense of mainline. And the percentage that want that is greater than 1%, as you seem to imply. Ask the top third at any large regional like Skywest, ASA, ExpressJet, Republic, etc and you will find many who have no intention or hope of moving on and are willing to fight for everything they can get. And since they pay more in dues than a regional newhire trying to build time, their voices will be heard.
#283
This thread is going to drift off into speculative nonsense and irrelevancy if someone doesn't step up and speak on behalf of DPA. I don't know if it will be one of the 3 named officers or someone else, but it better be soon.
If that website is all they got, it will be a darn shame.
Tim? Frank? Ira?
If that website is all they got, it will be a darn shame.
Tim? Frank? Ira?
Last edited by Check Essential; 09-21-2010 at 12:13 PM.
#284
I understand that...but it doesn't change the fact that Compass was the *best* opportunity Delta pilots had to recapture the large small jet flying that apparently is the biggest threat to their careers.
And they seemingly walked away from it without a second thought.
If Compass had been kept under mainline ALPA, wouldn't it have strengthened DALPA's their case for accreting that flying? Sure, DALPA would have had to take the Compass pilots too (which apparently will happen anyway) but I imagine a staple along with some sort of fence could have been negotiated.
I'll be the first to admit I don't know the ins & outs of Compass/Delta/NWA and certainly don't know the internal politics...but at least for a while, Compass was owned by Delta and their pilots represented by DALPA (unlike Comair & Mesaba)...I'm not sure the process going forward will be any less complicated than that.
And they seemingly walked away from it without a second thought.
If Compass had been kept under mainline ALPA, its goals would have been a conflict of interest with DALPA. (regional vs mainline) Plus it is likely Moak knew they were going to be sold at some point down the road.
I'll be the first to admit I don't know the ins & outs of Compass/Delta/NWA and certainly don't know the internal politics...but at least for a while, Compass was owned by Delta and their pilots represented by DALPA (unlike Comair & Mesaba)...I'm not sure the process going forward will be any less complicated than that.
#285
Moderator
Joined APC: Oct 2006
Position: B757/767
Posts: 13,088
If Compass had been kept under mainline ALPA, wouldn't it have strengthened DALPA's their case for accreting that flying? Sure, DALPA would have had to take the Compass pilots too (which apparently will happen anyway) but I imagine a staple along with some sort of fence could have been negotiated.
I'll be the first to admit I don't know the ins & outs of Compass/Delta/NWA and certainly don't know the internal politics...but at least for a while, Compass was owned by Delta and their pilots represented by DALPA (unlike Comair & Mesaba)...I'm not sure the process going forward will be any less complicated than that.
#286
#287
#288
BE IT RESOLVED: Since ALPA represents a large contingent of airlines, and whereas the vast majority of those airlines make far less than the legacy airlines, in order for the ALPA MEC to be in touch with his constituency, that his pay reflect the pay of the captains in ALL of those airlines, not just the three highest ones... AND that that pay now be based on an average of the highest paying captain at all member airlines under the ALPA stewardship.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that his retirement hereby be null and void as is the majority of his constituency
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that since NO commuter receives a housing allowance in the city to which he must commute, that that allowance hereby be revoked indefinitely.
Sorry for the run on... but this kind of "take it back" campaign won't even see the light of day in Herndon. Guaranteed
#289
To me, if the guys behind DPA want to form another union then do it for the right reasons and do what is right for Delta pilots and don't presume to be in charge. Allow the group to chose who they want if so inclined.
What was it Lincoln said: nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power.
Which is my issue with elections, if I can't truly trust the people I elect (speaking of congress), how in the world can I trust people who I don't elect and are not held accountable? Speaking of dopey.
What was it Lincoln said: nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power.
Which is my issue with elections, if I can't truly trust the people I elect (speaking of congress), how in the world can I trust people who I don't elect and are not held accountable? Speaking of dopey.
#290
:-)
Joined APC: Feb 2007
Posts: 7,339
I understand that...but it doesn't change the fact that Compass was the *best* opportunity Delta pilots had to recapture the large small jet flying that apparently is the biggest threat to their careers.
And they seemingly walked away from it without a second thought.
If Compass had been kept under mainline ALPA, wouldn't it have strengthened DALPA's their case for accreting that flying? Sure, DALPA would have had to take the Compass pilots too (which apparently will happen anyway) but I imagine a staple along with some sort of fence could have been negotiated.
I'll be the first to admit I don't know the ins & outs of Compass/Delta/NWA and certainly don't know the internal politics...but at least for a while, Compass was owned by Delta and their pilots represented by DALPA (unlike Comair & Mesaba)...I'm not sure the process going forward will be any less complicated than that.
And they seemingly walked away from it without a second thought.
If Compass had been kept under mainline ALPA, wouldn't it have strengthened DALPA's their case for accreting that flying? Sure, DALPA would have had to take the Compass pilots too (which apparently will happen anyway) but I imagine a staple along with some sort of fence could have been negotiated.
I'll be the first to admit I don't know the ins & outs of Compass/Delta/NWA and certainly don't know the internal politics...but at least for a while, Compass was owned by Delta and their pilots represented by DALPA (unlike Comair & Mesaba)...I'm not sure the process going forward will be any less complicated than that.
The problem with scope recapture is how management wants to approach it. In the 2012 contract DALPA could theoretically make section 1 one sentence: "All Delta Flying will be done by Delta seniority list pilots under the provisions of this CBA". It is now up to management to comply with that provision, this is where things could get ugly. Management can then say that they will have to merge with skywest/ASA, comair, compass, etc. Since they don't have the cash to buy out the contracts of these companies and operate the jets at mainline. Then you face the SLI of all the regionals with the mainline. This is the situation ALPA will do whatever it takes to avoid.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Lbell911
Regional
23
04-22-2012 11:33 AM