Search

Notices
Hangar Talk For non-aviation-related discussion and aviation threads that don't belong elsewhere

Ukraine conflict

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 11-06-2023, 06:13 PM
  #1801  
Gets Everyday Off
 
TransWorld's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Aug 2016
Position: Fully Retired
Posts: 7,000
Default

As a reminder, the Marshall Plan was offered to the Soviet Union. They turned it down. And they blocked all aide to the Eastern Europe block behind the Iron Curtain, as Churchill so memorably described them.
TransWorld is offline  
Old 11-06-2023, 06:26 PM
  #1802  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Oct 2009
Posts: 788
Default

Originally Posted by TransWorld
As a reminder, the Marshall Plan was offered to the Soviet Union. They turned it down. And they blocked all aide to the Eastern Europe block behind the Iron Curtain, as Churchill so memorably described them.
That is a good reminder indeed.
Surprisingly it is not a well-known fact in the West.
MaxQ is offline  
Old 11-06-2023, 08:14 PM
  #1803  
Perennial Reserve
 
Excargodog's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Jan 2018
Posts: 12,115
Default

Originally Posted by MaxQ
Cargo is correct in stating that it will be decades for recovery, if ever. He gives no indication of understanding that it is not the immediate pressing concern.
Every Slav knows it is their fate to continually rebuild their destroyed cathedrals.

Arguably Poland has yet to recover from WW2, and to some degree never will. Same for all the former Soviet Republics, and Russia, and on and on. (Viet Nam, Afghanistan....both with the Russians, then with Americans...Algeria)
This fate once again awaits Ukraine. The Ukrainians know this. They made the decision to fight…
WHO made the decision to fight?
It’s a CONSCRIPT army. Those running the government made the decision.

Those who wanted to enlist did so while others fled the country or got (often bogus) medical deferments until Zelensky fired everybody in the recruiting offices for taking bribes. But now Ukraine is running out of manpower. Even their senior military leaders have said so. Even if they had more weapons, they simply don’t have the manpower to prevail. Not my opinion, Ukrainian senior military leaderships opinion. Look at the facts.






Soldiers in Ukraine are veering increasingly older as the country grapples with a shortage of soldiers after roughly 20 months of brutal fighting against Russia.

As countless casualties have hampered Ukraine's forces, the average age of a soldier in the country is currently around 43 years old, Time magazine reported last week.

That average is up by nearly 10 years from March 2022, one month after the war began, when the average age of a Ukrainian soldier was between 30 and 35 years old, according to FT.

"They're grown men now, and they aren't that healthy to begin with," a close aide to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy told Time. "This is Ukraine. Not Scandinavia.Ukraine does not release the number of deaths or injuries among its troops, but Western officials said in August the war's total casualty (killed and injured) toll was nearing 500,000.

As the war drags on, Zelenskyy is concerned international support for the country is waning, he told Time. Less than half of Americans still support Congress giving more weapons to Ukraine, according to an October Reuters poll, where 35% disagreed and the remaining respondents were unsure.

A longtime member of Zelenskyy's team told Time the president feels betrayed by Ukraine's Western allies who he sees as having only given the country what it needs to survive the war but not beat Russia for good.

As American lawmakers squabble over whether to continue funding Ukraine, however, the country's personnel problems may be more dire than a lack of equipment.When the war first began in February 2022, Ukrainian recruits were plentiful; people volunteered in droves to defend their land from Russian invaders, while a mass mobilization effort that forbade nearly all men between the ages of 18 and 60 from leaving the country bolstered troop numbers early-on.

But recruitment is significantly down these days, Time reported, and the country is struggling to keep combat-age men from fleeing.

In August, Zelenskyy fired the head of the draft offices in every region of the country amid concerns of conscription corruption. But the move backfired, a Ukrainian senior military officer told Time, and slowed recruitment efforts to an effective stop.

Ukraine is also one of the oldest countries in the world with one in four people over the age of 60.
Demographics aren’t destiny but they are damn close. Before the war Ukraine had one of the lowest fertility rates in Europe and it’s gone down since that time. Current population growth rate is -0.5% annually. And it can only get worse. There are 7 million Ukrainian refugees in EU countries (of a 2020 population of 44 million) and another million plus in Russia. 70% of the Ukrainian refugees are women and children and every day they spend as a refugee in a country not actively at war makes it that more unlikely they will ever come back to Ukraine





I’m not suggesting anyone should like those facts - H€||, I don’t LIKE those facts, but that doesn’t stop them from being facts.
Excargodog is offline  
Old 11-07-2023, 03:32 PM
  #1804  
Prime Minister/Moderator
 
rickair7777's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Jan 2006
Position: Engines Turn Or People Swim
Posts: 40,047
Default

Originally Posted by Excargodog
WHO made the decision to fight?
It’s a CONSCRIPT army. Those running the government made the decision.

Those who wanted to enlist did so while others fled the country or got (often bogus) medical deferments until Zelensky fired everybody in the recruiting offices for taking bribes. But now Ukraine is running out of manpower. Even their senior military leaders have said so. Even if they had more weapons, they simply don’t have the manpower to prevail. Not my opinion, Ukrainian senior military leaderships opinion. Look at the facts.
The overall mood in UA is to fight.

There will always be a few draft dodgers, especially in a localized conflict where you can hop a cross a border or two and enjoy a good lifestyle in comfort.

I think you're taking our all volunteer force for granted.

And yes I think other nations should extradite those who broke UA law. That's a very broadly established system in the western world in particular. Even Venezuela looks to be fixing to return Fat Leonard to sender, and DPRK just sent a US deserter back.
rickair7777 is offline  
Old 11-07-2023, 08:16 PM
  #1805  
Perennial Reserve
 
Excargodog's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Jan 2018
Posts: 12,115
Default

Originally Posted by rickair7777
The overall mood in UA is to fight.

There will always be a few draft dodgers, especially in a localized conflict where you can hop a cross a border or two and enjoy a good lifestyle in comfort.

I think you're taking our all volunteer force for granted.

And yes I think other nations should extradite those who broke UA law. That's a very broadly established system in the western world in particular. Even Venezuela looks to be fixing to return Fat Leonard to sender, and DPRK just sent a US deserter back.
I did my 20 as did my father before me. And you certainly can’t win them all, we’ve definitely proved that. But this will AT BEST be a Pyrrhic victory and more than likely a Pyrrhic loss. Consider the demographics. Male life expectancy in Ukraine was only 65 BEFORE this war. And they are conscripting all the way up to age 60. And in the course of the last year and a half, the age of the average Ukrainian soldier has gone from mid-30s to mid-40s. That requires both a hellacious attrition of the young and a drafting of some seriously aged boots.

Nor does the fact that they wish to fight to the last man obligate us to fund it.

As for Venezuela and the DPRK, I wouldn’t read too much into them not wanting to keep either man. Both were illegal immigrants.




"When I talk, for example, with mortar operators, and the guys tell me: we have finally received as much ammunition as we have ever received in this war, and we are destroying an orcish (Russian) stronghold, but there is no one to go in because the infantry has run out," Dykyi said.

“And, unfortunately, I do hear similar things, to put it mildly; this is not just a one-off case that surprised me a lot.”

The former company commander of the Aidar battalion also said that ongoing mobilization is underway in Ukraine, but it "barely covers our losses.""We need a powerful wave of mobilization to create a numerical advantage over our enemies at least on this occasion, for the first time in the war," Dykyi added.

“We have never fought with an overwhelming number, we have always been fighting in the minority.”Dykyi said that although about a million people have been mobilized in Ukraine — 800,000 in the Armed Forces and 200,000 in other armed groups — there are actually far fewer people on the frontline compared to the 400,000 troops that Russia has concentrated there.

"Four hundred thousand is the number of orcs (Russians) in the four occupied oblasts, and that's it," he said.

“This is a real army at the front and in its immediate rear, within tens of kilometers. Those 400,000 do not include all their logistics, all their headquarters, and all their rear support. By the way, none of their wounded are included, because they are immediately taken out and are not included in this figure, nor is their entire medical care. While we have one million — this includes the army at the front, the entire northern border, where we have to keep a lot of troops, and hundreds of thousands of wounded soldiers who are being treated but not taken off the hospitalization schedule because they have to return to their unit after treatment. All military infirmaries, rear logistics, all warehouses, and even military enlistment offices — this is our million. This is not the same as one million at the front.”

Ukraine has not disclosed the number of soldiers at the front, "but let's just say that it has never come close to the figure of 400,000," the former Aidar company commander said.Dykyi said that Ukraine's technological advantage in terms of its modern Western weapons systems is not so great that it alone can compensate for the difference in troop numbers.

Earlier, in an op-ed published by the UK weekly news magazine the Economist on Nov. 1, Armed Forces Commander-in-Chief Valerii Zaluzhnyi said that Ukraine needs to expand the category of people who can be mobilized.

The top general called building up reserves one of his main priorities.

"Russia has failed to capitalize on its hefty manpower advantage because (Russian dictator) Vladimir Putin is worried that a general mobilization might spark a political crisis, and because Russia cannot train and equip enough people," he said.

“However, our capacity to train reserves on our own territory is also limited.”


Last edited by Excargodog; 11-07-2023 at 08:39 PM.
Excargodog is offline  
Old 11-08-2023, 05:53 AM
  #1806  
Perennial Reserve
 
Excargodog's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Jan 2018
Posts: 12,115
Default


https://dnyuz.com/2023/11/08/if-not-...-for-the-call/
An excerpt:

About 43,000 women now serve in the Ukrainian military, according to the ministry of defense, an increase of about 40 percent since 2021, the year before Russia’s full-scale invasion. The proportional increase is less than the male fighting force, which has more than tripled over the same period.

Ukrainian women are fighting in combat in southeastern Ukraine now. In several steps since the invasion, the military abolished restrictions that kept women from roles such as machine gunner, tank commander and sniper, and lifted rules prohibiting women from driving trucks. It raised the age limit for female recruits, previously 40, to 60, the same as for men.

Earlier in the full-scale war, women had taken combat roles in paramilitary groups or by skirting rules. And they have been wounded, captured and killed, though the military does not release casualty figures for either men or women.

The Ukrainian Army’s outreach to women is a step toward equality, to be sure, but one that also reflects the tremendous toll the war has exacted.

The hundreds of thousands of men who wanted to volunteer at the start of the war, many lining up on Day 1, have already joined; many are dead or wounded. Ukraine now needs to mobilize and train many more soldiers to sustain its resistance to the Russian invasion, even as men are increasingly dodging the draft.
Excargodog is offline  
Old 11-08-2023, 09:13 AM
  #1807  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Oct 2009
Posts: 788
Default

Originally Posted by rickair7777
The overall mood in UA is to fight.

There will always be a few draft dodgers, especially in a localized conflict where you can hop a cross a border or two and enjoy a good lifestyle in comfort.

I think you're taking our all volunteer force for granted.

And yes I think other nations should extradite those who broke UA law. That's a very broadly established system in the western world in particular. Even Venezuela looks to be fixing to return Fat Leonard to sender, and DPRK just sent a US deserter back.
Any country that fully mobilizes for a war will have conscription. Just as the USA did in WW2.
The fact that a citizen doesn't rush to join up doesn't mean that they will be reluctant or sullen. It just means they would rather let someone else fill the slot. The feedback I get is that there are very few who oppose the war. They know quite well who they are fighting. Cargo claiming that Ukraine having conscripts is indicative of deeper issues is just plain wrong.

It takes an army made up of volunteers and conscripts to actually reflect the makeup of the Nation. An all-volunteer military creates imbalances that have their own social/political pathologies.

If there is a general sense of being against the war, then yes, draftees will be recalcitrant and probably not contribute much while in uniform.
This probably is an apt description of many of the Russian soldiers sent to Ukraine. They don't feel invested in the war. They quickly learn they are the invaders. They realize this IS NOT their chance to repeat the heroism of their Grandfathers repelling a racist foe bent on exterminating them as a People. They don't share Putin's vision that Ukraine is not really a Nation, so it doesn't actually exist.

So yeah, they really don't want to be there.
MaxQ is offline  
Old 11-08-2023, 09:35 AM
  #1808  
Perennial Reserve
 
Excargodog's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Jan 2018
Posts: 12,115
Default

I don’t like Putin or his policies. Unfortunately the Russian people do not appear to share that opinion.



Nor is there any indication that a successor would be much of an improvement.

If our cultural values were universal values there never would have been a Nazi Germany or a militant imperial Japan

Last edited by Excargodog; 11-08-2023 at 09:47 AM.
Excargodog is offline  
Old 11-08-2023, 04:02 PM
  #1809  
Gets Everyday Off
 
TransWorld's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Aug 2016
Position: Fully Retired
Posts: 7,000
Default

Originally Posted by Excargodog
I don’t like Putin or his policies. Unfortunately the Russian people do not appear to share that opinion.



Nor is there any indication that a successor would be much of an improvement.

If our cultural values were universal values there never would have been a Nazi Germany or a militant imperial Japan
What percentage approve for fear of reprisal? Or lack of knowledge due to propaganda?

I knew a professor who kept speaking out against the Soviet government policy. He was sent from Moscow to Siberia, three times. Finally he was brought to the US, under asylum.
TransWorld is offline  
Old 11-08-2023, 06:54 PM
  #1810  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Apr 2011
Posts: 1,831
Default

Originally Posted by TransWorld
What percentage approve for fear of reprisal? Or lack of knowledge due to propaganda?

I knew a professor who kept speaking out against the Soviet government policy. He was sent from Moscow to Siberia, three times. Finally he was brought to the US, under asylum.
And…

So what’s it going take to end the bloodbath way over there. This time round. All ears
METO Guido is offline  
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Boeing Aviator
United
18
03-22-2022 11:04 AM
decrabbitz
FedEx
8
09-18-2021 10:22 PM
HerkDriver
Cargo
5
09-18-2007 01:56 PM
DiamondZ
Cargo
16
03-22-2007 10:38 AM
RockBottom
Hangar Talk
0
08-22-2006 07:35 AM

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



Your Privacy Choices