Close Call at JFK
#131
That could be policy at your last carrier, but I don't think that's a reg.
In the two jets I have time in, the CRJ lacks a tiller on the FO side (so limited to +/- 8 deg with the rudders if the FO is driving), and there is a tiller on the 320, but I only ever used it in the sim.
In the two jets I have time in, the CRJ lacks a tiller on the FO side (so limited to +/- 8 deg with the rudders if the FO is driving), and there is a tiller on the 320, but I only ever used it in the sim.
#132
#133
im not some old and busted captain. Hell I’m not even 40, but I’ve been a captain here for almost a decade. I do know the control freak whackadoodles exist though.
That being said….A lot of our new hires over the years have literally never made a PA ever or are way out of practice. On the 190 it was split duty, and they had to learn. Then the AAL mentality started permeating. Then practically policy (but not really) that I do it all. I still offered but half refused. Then the 190 went away and almost no one wanted to do them on my new fleet so I stopped asking. Many FO’s general lack of awareness of the timing of the PAs, much less the content is palpable, during the few trips I’ve done since the switch. I’m not going to listen to them talk, but Half the time I have to show them the button (if it even works after so many years of disuse), how not talk over the FA’s PA, and when to make them, etc. Stupid house cleaning crap that I’m sure is an annoying distraction for everyone, and it’s not their fault. It would have normally been ironed in a loft sim or on IOE. To top it off the captains have to break their reflexes that go back to the 727… (hand motion for gear much?!?). So yeah, we’re all professionals, but we are breaking the yoke of 90 years of ancestor worship this month.
That being said….A lot of our new hires over the years have literally never made a PA ever or are way out of practice. On the 190 it was split duty, and they had to learn. Then the AAL mentality started permeating. Then practically policy (but not really) that I do it all. I still offered but half refused. Then the 190 went away and almost no one wanted to do them on my new fleet so I stopped asking. Many FO’s general lack of awareness of the timing of the PAs, much less the content is palpable, during the few trips I’ve done since the switch. I’m not going to listen to them talk, but Half the time I have to show them the button (if it even works after so many years of disuse), how not talk over the FA’s PA, and when to make them, etc. Stupid house cleaning crap that I’m sure is an annoying distraction for everyone, and it’s not their fault. It would have normally been ironed in a loft sim or on IOE. To top it off the captains have to break their reflexes that go back to the 727… (hand motion for gear much?!?). So yeah, we’re all professionals, but we are breaking the yoke of 90 years of ancestor worship this month.
The wAAy we do it here is to assume the FO knows nothing and the sky god in the left seat is infallible. I guess you sit in the left seat long enough here and you don’t even realize the mentality, but it’s a solid percentage. Lotta guys still out there not letting the FO make cruise PAs…. We drink CRM light in these parts.
#134
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Jul 2021
Posts: 462
There are many, many captains here who make PAs over the FAs. Jump right into their spiel that no one listens to without listening ten times out of ten. When they interrupt a credit card sales pitch it’s great. When it’s the 4th PA over a 2 hour long flight at the crack of dawn, not so much. So now the captain is micromanaging you to make the prepare for takeoff PA while they’re still doing the demo in the back… the comedic side of it wears off pretty quick.
The wAAy we do it here is to assume the FO knows nothing and the sky god in the left seat is infallible. I guess you sit in the left seat long enough here and you don’t even realize the mentality, but it’s a solid percentage. Lotta guys still out there not letting the FO make cruise PAs…. We drink CRM light in these parts.
The wAAy we do it here is to assume the FO knows nothing and the sky god in the left seat is infallible. I guess you sit in the left seat long enough here and you don’t even realize the mentality, but it’s a solid percentage. Lotta guys still out there not letting the FO make cruise PAs…. We drink CRM light in these parts.
#135
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Apr 2011
Posts: 1,535
Hence the reason the PM is now tasked with the PA’s. Are there some CA’s who still want to micromanage the PA’s? Yes, certainly. Most of that older guard will be retiring within a few years anyway, so that mentality will die off.
#136
Gets Weekends Off
Thread Starter
Joined APC: Jul 2006
Posts: 2,900
I upgraded 6 years ago. I was considered part of the “newer” generation of Captains (hired in 2000) that were slowly breaking away from the years and years of ancestral worship plaguing this airline. I actively involve the F/O in every decision I make… hey, how’s this arrival fuel, wanna add more? Hey whaddaya think about this alternate.. etc, etc. Most of them look at me like I was from another planet. Nowadays it’s slowly getting better.
So I also and constantly offered the F/O every PA imaginable. Guess what.. maybe 1 out of 100 would take me up on it. Everyone else? “They don’t pay me enough to make PAs.” Ok then.
THAT’s probably why the reaction is what it is today. It’s not that it’s not being offered - it’s just that captains are probably sick of offering them and being told no thanks over and over again.
FYI, just about 100% of F/Os I fly with are former Captains and could do the job as well or even better than I can, right now, today.
So I also and constantly offered the F/O every PA imaginable. Guess what.. maybe 1 out of 100 would take me up on it. Everyone else? “They don’t pay me enough to make PAs.” Ok then.
THAT’s probably why the reaction is what it is today. It’s not that it’s not being offered - it’s just that captains are probably sick of offering them and being told no thanks over and over again.
FYI, just about 100% of F/Os I fly with are former Captains and could do the job as well or even better than I can, right now, today.
#137
I upgraded 6 years ago. I was considered part of the “newer” generation of Captains (hired in 2000) that were slowly breaking away from the years and years of ancestral worship plaguing this airline. I actively involve the F/O in every decision I make… hey, how’s this arrival fuel, wanna add more? Hey whaddaya think about this alternate.. etc, etc. Most of them look at me like I was from another planet. Nowadays it’s slowly getting better.
So I also and constantly offered the F/O every PA imaginable. Guess what.. maybe 1 out of 100 would take me up on it. Everyone else? “They don’t pay me enough to make PAs.” Ok then.
THAT’s probably why the reaction is what it is today. It’s not that it’s not being offered - it’s just that captains are probably sick of offering them and being told no thanks over and over again.
FYI, just about 100% of F/Os I fly with are former Captains and could do the job as well or even better than I can, right now, today.
So I also and constantly offered the F/O every PA imaginable. Guess what.. maybe 1 out of 100 would take me up on it. Everyone else? “They don’t pay me enough to make PAs.” Ok then.
THAT’s probably why the reaction is what it is today. It’s not that it’s not being offered - it’s just that captains are probably sick of offering them and being told no thanks over and over again.
FYI, just about 100% of F/Os I fly with are former Captains and could do the job as well or even better than I can, right now, today.
“I know what the new procedure is, but the captain makes PAs so I will be doing them” isn’t just being stuck in a rut though.
Still, most are great. I think we have a higher percentage of god captains that UAL or DAL though. Something about the academy -> pooping on a stick-> aa pipeline lol
#138
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Sep 2015
Position: UNA
Posts: 4,475
Betcha the Delta guy was using the HUD for takeoff. They seem to love the thing over there (they still like to play fighter pilot). You can't see any kind of distance when you're staring through that thing, especially at night and focused on its content 6 inches in front of you. Shouldn't be used for takeoff but they all do every time I've jumped on them. The FO was probably heads down looking at the gauges.
#139
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Jun 2019
Posts: 373
Sadly this is pretty true. A lot of the old left seat guys are also getting butt hurt that their is a hiring boom and most of the new FOs are sub 35 years old. They think beings at a regional and being a regional jet Captain is like flying left seat in a 172…
Honestly though most issues stem from the older guys at AA being from a completely different era and are all former military and never worked at a regional. They are just frankly out of touch with reality on a lot of things.
It’s a different world these days and thankfully AA will be a completely new airline so to speak in 5 years or so with all the retirements.
#140
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Apr 2011
Posts: 1,535
Sadly this is pretty true. A lot of the old left seat guys are also getting butt hurt that their is a hiring boom and most of the new FOs are sub 35 years old. They think beings at a regional and being a regional jet Captain is like flying left seat in a 172…
Honestly though most issues stem from the older guys at AA being from a completely different era and are all former military and never worked at a regional. They are just frankly out of touch with reality on a lot of things.
It’s a different world these days and thankfully AA will be a completely new airline so to speak in 5 years or so with all the retirements.
Honestly though most issues stem from the older guys at AA being from a completely different era and are all former military and never worked at a regional. They are just frankly out of touch with reality on a lot of things.
It’s a different world these days and thankfully AA will be a completely new airline so to speak in 5 years or so with all the retirements.
I’ve been here a decade. Most of the captains I flew with in the first five years or so were former military, and I happen to come from a purely civilian, Regional Airline background. With maybe a handful of exceptions, nearly every one of those former military guys was awesome to fly with in every way. Team players, valued my input, easy to work with, often asked if I wanted to do PA’s (no thanks, lol, like aa73 said), always made a point of not interrupting the FA’s PA’s, worked well with their entire crew, always tried to keep us both in the green, and on and on. They were captains to be emulated.
Who knows? Maybe my experience at the LAX and MIA bases is different than say DFW or the other bases. Maybe. I hope not.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post